19th-century quilt offers peek into family history

Sometime before 1866, Betsey Pinkham sewed a friendship quilt from pieces of family garments.
The quilt was made with scraps of fabric in blues and tans and burgundies, in velvet and cotton and a piece or two of brocade. Some pieces are torn. Some pieces have numbers on them that appear to be dates; but if that is so, one of the years, 1883, is after the death of Pinkham. In investigating this puzzle, an interesting story unfurled.
Betsey was the wife of Nathan Pinkham Sr., born in Maine, and a convert to Joseph Smith and the Mormon Church. For a time the Pinkhams lived on a farm near Far West, Mo. In 1836 Joseph Smith and others had purchased land in this area, laid cornerstones for a temple and begun to build a community. For some time all went well, but in 1837 tensions boiled over between the local non-Mormon settlers and the now-thriving and quickly growing Mormon settlements.
A kind of guerrilla warfare began. The Mormon farms were raided; crops were burned and vandalism occurred in an effort to force the new settlers to move. The Mormon hierarchy, in response, created a group called the Destruction Band, both for protection and retaliation. Members were known to meet at Nathan Pinkham's house, and it is likely that Nathan Jr. was a member of this band of 12, which would later have a fearful reputation as the "Danites."
Pinkham Jr. was captured and held by the Missouri Militia for a time in October 1838 but escaped during the battle of Cold Creek, fought between Mormons and the militia. His mother, Betsey, and her other children (Elmire, Sumner and Caroline) were with those driven from their homes by the order of Gov. Lilburn Boggs. It is unclear if Nathan Sr. arrived in Quincy with the family when it crossed the river into Quincy 1839.
Nathan Pinkham Jr. went into the livery business in Quincy, and in 1842 married Lucy Eliza Williams, whose father, Frederick Granger Williams, also had lived in Far West. Williams had been a scribe to Joseph Smith but was removed from his position as second counselor in First Presidency in 1837, then baptized back into the church in Nauvoo in 1840 by Joseph Smith himself.
Nathan and Lucy had one child who died in 1845 and was followed in death by Lucy Williams Pinkham that same year. Pinkham did not follow the westward migration of the Mormons when they left Nauvoo in 1847.
After a few years, Nathan Pinkham moved his livery to the north side of Maine between Third and Fourth. An 1854 advertisement called it a "Boarding School for Horses" and boastfully proclaimed, "This establishment 110 feet on Main Street and extending 200 feet deep northward, is the most commodious and best arranged and thoroughly equipped Brick-Stable Depot west of the Alleghenies and east of the Sierra Nevada Mountains." The stable could house 150 horses and 100 carriages, and had rentals to meet every need.
Pinkham also operated the omnibus line -- a horse-drawn conveyance to carry passengers up the hill from the train depot or boat dock to the Quincy House or other hotels in the city.
In 1866 he married Ellen Davis, and they had one daughter, Carro May Pinkham. (She would grow up to marry T.E. Thompson and donate her Grandmother Betsy's quilt to the Historical Society).
Pinkham made a fortune during the Civil War selling "forage" to the army for its horses and mules. By 1852, the family lived in a large brick home on the southeast corner of Fourteenth and Maine. The house was later torn down to accommodate the building of the Quincy Clinic.
Pinkham was a shrewd entrepreneur. In 1860 his holdings were appraised for taxes at $40,000. By 1870 his property and holdings were valued at $250,000.
Pinkham's brother, Sumner, did go west, ending up in Idaho. He lived there for about 13 years and for a time was sheriff of Boise County.
In July 1865, shortly after a visit to his mother in Quincy, Sumner returned to Idaho City and tangled with an intoxicated gunfighter named J. "Ferd" Patterson. An argument followed, and Patterson shot Pinkham twice, killing him. Patterson fled, but was soon arrested by a sheriff's posse. Sumner Pinkham was evidently a popular man, as it was reported that over 1,500 mourners followed his hearse to the graveyard.
In Quincy in 1863, Nathan Pinkham renovated the second story of his livery into a large theater. A few years later, he closed the downstairs livery stable and again renovated the entire property into a grand entertainment hall. Pinkham Hall was an opulent building with gilt ornamentation and a large dome in the center of the ceiling, which rose over 70 feet and featured good acoustics and air circulation.
The theater booked the big names on the traveling show circuit, and hosted rallies and large meetings. Its run as the premier showplace in Quincy abruptly ended when fire destroyed the building and most of the block in September 1879.
Nathan Pinkham died in 1889, leaving an odd will that left his widow without money or the ability to sell any property for 20 years. His daughter, Caro May Thompson, sued the estate and her mother as executrix to overturn the will. It was a friendly lawsuit, as both women believed the provisions were "peculiar" and "objectionable." Testimony revealed that Pinkham had been in failing mental health.
The trigger for his odd behavior, according to witnesses as reported by The Quincy Daily Journal, was that "during the last two years of his life, ... after the event of his killing a strange cow that attempted to enter his yard, [using] an ax, he acted strangely."
The will was overturned by a jury. The Pinkham family quilt is a window into history, created from odd-shaped pieces of garments worn by those who helped build our city.
Beth Lane is the author of "Lies Told Under Oath," the story of the 1912 Pfanschmidt murders near Payson. She is executive director of the Historical Society of Quincy and Adams County.
Sources
"A Transaction," Quincy Daily Whig, Thursday, July 31, 1856
"Begun the Water Works" Quincy Daily Herald, Tuesday, January 16, 1894
"Elbridge/Tufts," The Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints, "Pedigree Resource File," database, FamilySearch ( https://familysearch.org/ark/61902/2:2:SRXZ-79F :accessed 2015-12-23), entry for Elbridge/Tufts/
"Far West, Missouri," ( http://josephsmithpapers.org/place/far-west-missouri ) accessed 2015-12-27
"Journal Excerpt of Joseph Holbrook, Far West, Missouri, 1835,",taken from the edition typed and edited by Mabel F. and Ward C. Holbrook, Bountiful, Utah, 1977
"Frederick B. Williams," Wikipedia ( https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Frederick_G_Williams ) accessed 2015-12-31
"Livery Stable and Boarding School for Horses," The Quincy Daily Whig, Wednesday, December 13, 1854
"Murder of a Former Citizen of Quincy," The Quincy Whig, Saturday, Sept. 2, 1865
"N. Pinkham's Livery Barn is Recalled," Quincy Daily Journal, Friday, July 18, 1913
Nathan Pinkham, "Illinois Deaths and Stillbirths 1916-1947" database, FamilySearch ( https://familysearch.org/ark:61903/1:1:N3Z4-WDN : accessed Dec. 31, 2015) Nathan Pinkham in entry for Carro May Thompson, April 24, 1937; Public Board of Health Archives, Springfield, FHL microfilm 1,786,730
Pinkham, Nathan, History of Adams County, 1879
Quincy Memorial Park Cemetery and Early Quincy Cemetery, Great River Genealogical Society, 1993
"Rats and Snakes," Quincy Daily Herald, Nov. 22, 1893
"Set Aside," Quincy Daily Journal, Friday, April 24, 1891
"State of Illinois, County of Adams," Quincy Daily Herald, Sunday, March 22, 1891
"The Quincy Omnibus line," Quincy Daily Whig, Wednesday, May 6, 1857
"The Historical Record: The Twelve Apostles," No 4, April, 1856, Pub: Andrew Jenson, Salt Lake City, Utah
"Under the Dome," Quincy Daily Herald, Friday, April 24, 1891
Note: I also used Accession records of the Historical Society of Quincy and Adams County.





