Anna Benneson McMahan: In the haunts of Byron, Shelley and Shakespeare

Anna Benneson McMahan’s early life in Quincy was inspired by parentage possessed with a belief in a broad cultural education and imbued with pioneer fortitude and acumen.
From this spirited incubator McMahan became one of the most scholarly women Quincy has engendered. Among her lifetime achievements were seven books on classical literary works published by an established Chicago literary publisher, A. C. McClurg. McMahan chiefly edited selected works and letters of classic poets and authors. She also was a critic who reviewed for literary journals, primarily one called the Dial.
Born in 1846 her accomplishments were unusual for a woman of her generation. A distinguished native of the community for nearly 50 years, McMahan’s notable literary legacy is unremembered.
Her younger sister by five years, Cora, achieved recognition as an early woman lawyer and was one of the first women accepted into a co-educational university to obtain her higher degrees. Both sisters were scholars who wrote, lectured and traveled abroad. While there are many parallels in their lives Cora remained a single woman.
The daughter of Robert and Electa Ann Benneson, Anna was the second of four sisters (Alice, Anna, Susan Caroline (Lina) and Cora. Robert Benneson settled in Quincy in 1837 and married Electa Ann Park in 1842. Benneson became a wealthy businessman in the lumber industry, served on the school board for 16 years, considered the “patron saint” of the public school system in Quincy, and was a civic leader and alderman who was elected as mayor in 1859.
Anna’s youthful education was at home with her three sisters, all tutored by their proficient mother. She attended Quincy schools for a time but with the means to send her to school in the East Benneson went in Boston. There she attained the highest education available to women in what was comparable to a college degree. She developed an early affinity for classical literature that would remain a seminal significance in her life.
In 1868 when Benneson was 22, she married Kentucky born Dr. Robert W. McMahan, a surgeon who studied medicine in Philadelphia, practiced in McLean County and enlisted in the 146th Illinois Regiment for one year from 1864-1865. As a surgeon he served in Civil War hospitals in Memphis and Vicksburg. Later stationed in Quincy he set up a medical practice at war’s end. For a number of years the McMahans resided on Jersey just south of Maine Street. Dr. McMahan, 15 years his wife’s senior, later was appointed surgeon for the Soldiers’ and Sailors’ Home when the facility opened.
As a young well-educated married woman McMahan gravitated to a group of like-minded women headed by Sarah Denman, founder of the renowned Friends in Council study group chartered in 1869. A dedicated member she served as the Council president for six years. In a short time she became their teacher of literature and was called on to lecture and direct courses in Quincy and nearby towns. Due to demand for Mc-Mahan’s study courses she authored a guide, The Study Class, a Guide for the Student of English Literature, published in 1891 by A. C. McClurg.
The mother of two daughters, Una, born in 1871, and Florence, born in 1875, she continued her studious interests editing and publishing two 18th Century collections, the “Best Letters of Horace Walpole,” English art historian and man of letters, in 1890, and the “Best Letters of William Cowper,” English poet, in 1893.
In 1893 after 25 years of family life in Quincy the McMahans moved to Chicago when Dr. McMahan took a position in the medical division of the Atchison, Topeka & Santa Fe Railway. McMahan, invited to present a paper at the Congress of Women held in the Woman’s Building at the legendary Chicago World’s Columbian Exposition, spoke on “The New Motive in Fiction”on July 14, 1893. McMahan became active in the Chicago Woman’s Club and influenced by the larger metropolitan environment her interest in public affairs grew. In a gutsy request she convinced the editor-in chief of the Chicago Tribune to allow her to write editorials for the newspaper. The outcome was McMahan’s weekly column in the Tribune on public issues.
In November 1896 Robert McMahan died. Married 28 years his body was brought to Woodland Cemetery for burial. Her visit to Quincy the next year was noted in the newspaper along with the title of her talk “Imaginative Application of Scientific Thought in George Eliot’s Novels.”
With her daughters in their college years and the means and opportunity to travel and leisurely study classic poets and their work in a new light, McMahan sailed to Liverpool, England, arriving there in August 1899 for an extended stay, principally in Italy and England. After study in Italy preparing for her first book, she returned to visit in the fall of 1901 and gave a talk to Friends in Council titled “The Browning Pilgrimage.”
The antiquities and art treasures of Europe were of great interest to McMahan and are entwined in her published narratives. Her intrigue in the antiquities is evidenced on one of her trips to Rome in 1903. McMahan wrote a 10-page letter to Quincy friends in November of that year. She relayed new 13 B. C. archaeological discoveries a “stone’s throw” from Rome’s principal street created in honor of Augustus and of her privilege of descending into the underground passages of the excavation under the guidance of the engineer in charge. It is clear from the letter that her understanding of the antiquities was in accord with her classical interests in literature. While traveling in Europe she kept writing reviews for the Dial and other journals on literature and art books.
McMahan was inspired to pursue her literary work in the haunts of the poets she most admired, in the context of place. Three of McMahan’s books trace the influence of Italy’s landscape, setting, and art pieces on the works of British poets Percy Shelley, Lord Byron, and Robert and Elizabeth Barrett Browning. In England McMahan studied the stomping grounds of Wordsworth and Shakespeare. Her first book placing the author’s life and works to its larger surroundings was Florence in the Poetry of the Brownings published with more than 60 illustrations from photographs of the scenery and the art of Florence in 1904. Discussion and illustration of art, space, and time was integral to her work as she cast a reflective light on her subjects’ works.
Her historical travels were largely pilgrimages to enlighten this dialogue. “With Shelley in Italy” and “With Byron in Italy” were published in 1905 and 1906, respectively. In the introduction to the book on Shelley, McMahan wrote, “No attempt had previously been made to set (Shelly’s) poems in their original environment.”
In 1907 McMahan published a short story on Shakespeare’s “Twelfth Night” titled “Shakespeare’s Christmas Gift to Queen Bess in the Year 1596.” Another important work, “With Wordsworth in England,” came out the same year.
After writing five books in eight years McMahan’s productive study in Europe came to an end in 1908. A talk in Quincy in November 1909 was in conjunction with the publication of her last book, Shakespeare’s Love Story published that year. Mc-Mahan presented her theory of the meaning and purpose of the Shakespearean sonnets placing sonnets “in the pages we know of Shakespeare’s life.” The newspaper article extolled the author’s “fine position among the country’s literary characters.”
Her residence for the last decade of her life became Bryn Mawr, Pa., west of Philadelphia, where her daughter Una McMahan, a graduate of Smith College and graduate schools in Chicago, Berlin and Rome, was on the faculty at Bryn Mawr College for a few years. Una married Chicago lawyer Frank E. Harkness in October 1909 and Florence, a Wellesley College graduate, married Douglas E. Bonner of New York in September 1908.
Anna McMahan died in Bryn Mawr on Nov. 27, 1919. Her books remain on the shelves of libraries in Italy, Britain and America.
Iris Nelson is reference librarian and archivist at Quincy Public Library, a civic volunteer, and member of the Lincoln-Douglas Debate Interpretive Center Advisory Board and other historical organizations. She is a local historian and author.





