Bigamy a not-so-rare thing in the 1880s

When the criminal term of circuit court convened in Quincy in early 1893, there were 20 cases before the grand jury. The litany of charges would be mostly familiar to today's court watchers, but some crimes seem to have been eradicated by the Information Age.
In nearly every term of the court there were matters of bigamy to be adjudicated. Bigamy is "the crime of marrying somebody while being legally married to somebody else." Sometimes, everyone was guilty.
In August 1894, Hugo Bank returned to Quincy after an absence of 14 years, to find that his wife was now married to another man. In 1880 Bank and Anna Elizabeth Ritter married in Quincy at the German Methodist Church. A mere four months later, the groom left his bride weeping at the train station and embarked for Cincinnati. For the next year, Bank sent letters and some money from Ohio before moving to Denver and then Arizona. Then correspondence stopped. After 10 years, Bank wrote to the mayor and chief of police inquiring about his wife, but received no satisfactory answers. He returned to Quincy to see for himself.
On arrival, Bank discovered that less than a year after his leaving, his wife resumed her maiden name and on Oct. 12, 1881, married Andrew Jackson Grimmer. A.J. Grimmer had been one of Anna Elizabeth's suitors before her marriage to Bank.
Hugo Bank demanded that his wife acknowledge him and make a settlement of cash, or face prosecution. Bank-Grimmer declined to pay, and so the matter was put into the hands of attorneys. In 1893, the charge of bigamy carried a sentence of one to five years in the state penitentiary for the twice-married spouse. The other partner, in this case Andrew Grimmer, faced a misdemeanor charge for marrying a woman he knew to be married, which carried a penalty of one year in the county jail and a $500 fine.
Bank, who had run a wax-figure museum in Tucson, Ariz., hired attorneys Oscar P. Adams and William Schlagenhauf. Schlagenhauf was the son of the Rev. Schlagenhauf, who had performed the wedding ceremony for the Bankses.
Anna Eliza Ritter had been a highly respected young lady and a devout member of the Jersey Street German M.E. Church. But there had been a change. Mr. and Mrs. Grimmer had for some time been living above a tavern that they owned at Fourth and Broadway. The tavern had been raided by police and fined for being a "disorderly house." The church then expelled Anna Eliza Ritter Bank-Grimmer.
The Grimmers retained attorneys Overt and Vendeventer, who proposed to prove that Bank himself had a wife in Germany before coming to this country, and another left behind in Arizona. Bank retaliated with a civil suit for $20,000 against Grimmer for alienation of his wife's affections.
Nine months later the case came to trial. Bank did not appear in the courtroom, yet despite his absence, Mrs. Grimmer was found guilty and sentenced to a year and a half in the Chester Penitentiary. Bank did not return, as it turned out that he too had an extra spouse and would be thus liable to be arrested under the same charge. Shortly after sentencing, Mrs. Bank-Grimmer initiated a suit for divorce from her first husband on grounds of cruelty and desertion. Govert and Pape, now her attorneys, also filed for a new trial. Mrs. Bank alleged that her first marriage was not valid as Bank had a previous wife. Mr. Grimmer was acquitted of his misdemeanor charges. Govert also filed a clemency petition with Gov. John Peter Altgeld for Mrs. Grimmer, who had been certified as too ill to be sent to prison. A year after her conviction, the pardon came through.
At other times, the fault was entirely on one side. In 1910, a Quincy woman made a career of marrying war veterans. Lizzie Miller, (alias Mathilda Bosse), wife of William Miller since 1882, advertised for a husband. She presented herself as a missionary and member of the Quaker church. In 1907, using the name Mathilda Miller, Lizzie acquired a second husband in Dayton, Ohio, Henry C. Pate. By 1910 she was back in Quincy, and under the name Eva M. Miller, married George E. Armstrong on Dec. 7, 1910. He was a veteran and resident at the soldiers home.
Less than a month later, she took a fourth husband, also a resident of the soldiers home, Alexander M. Napple. They met on a crowded train, where he offered her his seat. Napple later saw an ad in a matrimonial paper bearing Lizzie Miller's name. Napple immediately replied and shortly after proposed. They were married on New Year's Day 1911, and moved into a rooming house near Sixth and Vermont. The owner of the home, Mrs. McKenzie, noticed the bride had two trunks, one marked "Lizzie Miller" and the other "Mathilda Pate."
Shortly after their marriage, Mr. Napple came home to a room stripped bare. The police that day were notified by two veterans that their wives had run away, and the descriptions of both wives "tallied almost exactly." When the two veterans met, the identity of the missing wife was unraveled, and notice went to all soldiers home officials in this part of the country. Lizzie Miller-Napple-Armstrong-Pate was arrested in Dayton, Ohio, where she was canvassing another soldiers home. She was returned to Quincy, where she pleaded guilty and was sentenced to one to five years in the Joliet penitentiary.
Beth Lane is the author of "Lies Told Under Oath," the story of the 1912 Pfanschmidt murders near Payson. She is executive director of the Historical Society of Quincy and Adams County.
Sources
"A Second Enoch Arden," Quincy Herald, Thursday, August 9, 1894
"At the Prison Gate," Quincy Whig, Thursday, June 6, 1895
"A woman is Guilty," Quincy Daily Herald, Wednesday, January 25, 1911
"Bank Was In the Same Boat," Quincy Daily Journal, Saturday, June 1, 1895
"Bigamist Arrested," Quincy Daily Journal, Thursday, Jan 19, 1911
"For A Wife's Affections," Quincy Herald, Tuesday, October 23, 1894
"Four Husbands in One Month" Quincy Daily Whig, Friday, Jan. 20, 1911
"He Claims His Wife," Quincy Morning Whig, Friday, August 10, 1894
"Late Brevities" Quincy Morning Whig, Saturday, June 13, 1895
"Marriage Register," Quincy Daily Herald, Dec. 17, 1910
"Quincy Woman Makes high Score in Matrimonial Game," Quincy Daily Whig, Sunday, January 29, 1911
"The Governor's Pardon," Quincy Herald, Monday, August 19, 1895
"The Grimmers Arrested," Quincy Herald, Thursday, August 9, 1894





