Local temperance movement paved way for prohibition

After 1785 when Dr. Benjamin Rush, the United States' leading physician at the time, published "An Inquiry into the Effects of Ardent Spirits upon the Human Body and Mind," the temperance movement became a mainstay of American life. It culminated in ratification of a Prohibition Amendment to the U.S. Constitution on Jan. 16, 1919.
The local movement began auspiciously. Quincyans formed their first temperance society in 1827, but it abruptly folded when bystanders spotted its president drinking in public. Soon, though, other groups formed: Sons of Temperance, Quincy Washingtonian Temperance and a branch of American Temperance Life Insurance, which sold policies only to abstaining men. Newspapers started publishing articles beseeching drinkers to denounce debauchery. Lyrics from "Temperance Hymn" in the Quincy Daily Whig on Oct. 24, 1853, included these lines: "Then drunkards shall from sleep awake/ Intemperance at once forsake/ Tho' pledged to abstinence they may/ Tho' much temptation lead astray."
Aligning itself state-wide, this local movement led to an Illinois law in 1851 prohibiting sales of alcohol in quantities less than a quart to anyone under the age of 18. The law also limited consumption to places of purchase. The legislature, though, repealed this law four years later.
The Civil War brought a standstill to the temperance movement as the nation struggled with its greatest crisis. Soon after the war, though, prohibitionists formed the Illinois Temperance Party to place candidates on state and national ballots, and Quincy established a charter. An Anti-Saloon League also formed here to go "from congregations to ballot boxes."
The Women's Christian Temperance Union (WCTU) headquartered in Evanston, Ill., chartered a unit in Quincy in 1877 and would eventually become one of Adams County's largest organizations, with over 400 members spread over eight towns. In promoting abstinence, the WCTU began an annual essay contest for children on the topic "What is the Harm in a Glass of Beer?" and formed a Young People's Temperance Society. More than 2,000 local children attending church-sponsored Sabbath Schools signed a temperance pledge and Quincy Public Schools began teaching scientific temperance.
Sir George Williams had founded the nondenominational Young Men's Christian Association in London on the principle of "muscular Christianity"-- the effort to build healthy bodies for fighting off temptations of drink and other evils, and a Quincy chapter began in 1883. Three years later, with many Civil War veterans suffering from drunkenness, Quincy's Soldiers and Sailors Home formed a Bible-based temperance league.
After the 1900 census, workers documented that Quincy had 133 saloons -- as many drinking establishments per capita as Chicago and St. Louis -- the city's 12 Protestant churches began "white ribbon" campaigns. The Rev. Parker Shields of Vermont Street Methodist Episcopal Church delivered a sermon reprinted in the Quincy Daily Whig on November 26, 1900, stating his stance and that of many other clergymen: "We have driven the saloons out of respectable society and next we shall drive it into the sewers and hell where it belongs."
Prior to Shields' condemnation of alcohol, his church had qualified its embrace of abstinence. The Quincy Daily Journal of Nov. 22, 1897, reiterated a bylaw of the Methodist Temperance Society: "Every member who joined the society pledged himself not to get drunk at any time except Fourth of July, Christmas, Thanksgiving, and election day."
Quincy Catholic churches included many members of Italian, Irish and, especially, German descent, traditional drinking cultures. These churches distinguished between "true temperance" and "prohibition." The Rev. Father Arsenius Fahle voiced this position in a speech delivered in German at St. Francis Hall and translated in the Quincy Daily Herald on Feb. 14, 1898. "It is the abuse, not the use that works the injury." There is no temperance in total abstinence for anything intended for man's happiness. In fact it is the most virulent form of intemperance."
By 1907 Missouri had become a temperate state with 38 dry countries and Illinois had 600 towns which did not sell alcohol. Four years later, Quincy rep. George H. Wilson introduced a bill in the Illinois House to give counties the option to prohibit the sale of alcohol. After the bill passed, Adams County placed a referendum before voters. Quincy's mayor and city council opposed the measure noting that saloons provided $70,000 a year in licensing revenues. Despite concerted church and organizational efforts, voters turned down the referendum.
The temperance movement continued relentlessly, though, and wary alcohol distributors began touting beer as a healthy alternative to hard liquor and spirits. Pabst Blue Ribbon made its marketing debut advertising itself as "the most nutritious beer brewed" and a "Budweiser Spells Temperance" campaign began. Even The Rev. John C. Orebaugh, a prominent clergyman and temperance advocate, distinguished between drinking and the medicinal use of alcohol in proclaiming Duffy's Pure Malt Whiskey a "God-given medicine."
After the United States entered World War I, the temperance movement made giant strides when, to conserve them for military use, President Woodrow Wilson limited beer brewers to 70 percent of the grains they had previously used. Later he banned the sale of alcohol to American troops. Many citizens at home seeking vengeance against the war's enemy, Germany, with its longstanding drinking tradition, further propelled the cause.
The temperance movement climaxed two months after the war ended with the Volstead Act and the 18th Amendment to the Constitution prohibiting the manufacture, sale, and transportation of intoxicating liquor.
After the celebrations, though, a backlash swept over the city. A speaker at Quincy Presbyterian Church charged that brewers had been German agents working to spread propaganda for the Kaiser. Intemperance became a valid reason for divorce. Police raided the Old Missouri Saloon at 325 Hampshire, a drinking establishment for 60 years, and poured out over 100 barrels of beer onto the streets. They later turned it into a makeshift temperance hall. Dwight, Ill., became the headquarters of the Keeley Institute, a nation-wide commercial venture which saw drunkenness as a disease and offered treatment. Local drugstores began selling "Keeley Cure" and other "medicines"--usually containing alcohol--for drunkards trying to stay on the wagon.
Joseph Newkirk is a local writer and photographer whose work has been widely published as a contributor to literary magazines, as a correspondent for Catholic Times, and for the past 23 years as a writer for the Library of Congress' Veterans History Project. He is a member of the reorganized Quincy Bicycle Club and has logged more than 10,000 miles on bicycles in his life.
Sources
The Cyclopedia of Temperance and Prohibition. New York: Funk & Wagnalls, 1891, pp.210, 291-93.
"A God-Given Medicine." Quincy Daily Journal, Feb. 13, 1907, p.3.
"Into Sewers and to Hell." Quincy Daily Journal, Nov. 26, 1900, p.5.
Merrick, George Byron. Old Times on the Upper Mississippi: The Recollections of a Steamboat Pilot
from 1854 to 1863, p.204.
Monahan, M. ed and compiler. A Text-Book of True Temperance, 2nd ed. New York: United States
Brewers Association, 1911, p.226.
"Sobieski is Optimistic." Quincy Daily Journal, Nov. 22, 1897, p.5.
"Teach Temperance." Quincy Daily Whig, Aug. 20, 1897, p.3.
"Temperance Hymn." Quincy Daily Whig, Oct. 24, 1853, p.2.
"Temperance and Sunday School." Quincy Daily Whig, April 25, 1853, p.3.
"True Temperance." Quincy Daily Herald, Feb. 14, 1898, p.8.
"Wilson's Bill is In." Quincy Daily Herald, Feb.14, 1911, p.3.





