Burton Cave

Along our stretch of the Mississippi, when the word “cave” is mentioned, most of the population thinks of Mark Twain Cave south of Hannibal, Mo. It is, however, not the only cave in the area.
Less than ten miles east of Quincy on Highway 104 is the small unincorporated town of Burton, Illinois. The first settlers in Burton Township arrived in 1825. There are two villages in the township, Burton and Newtown. The village of Burton was platted in 1836 by Elijah M. King. A post office was established at Burton in 1840.
On a steep hillside south of the town a cave mouth opens above the creek. It first came to settler’s attention in about 1830, according to Henry Asbury’s history. Likely it was known to the native population before that, but no record exists. A later history attributes its discovery to an area “snake hunt” in which the locals decided to rid their neighborhood of the reptiles. Apparently the population of snakes in the area was the stuff of horror tales and records say that “several hundred” were killed by settlers in one day on the hunt along Mill Creek. Along with the snakes, Tilford Hogan and Perry Klingingsmith discovered the cave.
The cave mouth is broad, easily seen, and over six feet in height at the entrance. Inside, the floors were reported to be muddy and quite slick in places. No electricity or lights have ever been installed, and the cave remains in its natural state.
The area became a popular picnic spot, courtesy of the wide entrance and relative simplicity of its layout. The cave formed during the glacial ages when water under the ice sheets trickled through cracks in the bed rock, dissolved the limestone and left a void. Groundwater then began to drip and create stalactites and stalagmites. One such pillar, formed where the drips from the top and the deposits from the floor met, was called The Devil’s Hitching Post. Another called The Spring rose up from the floor as deposits created a round column with a depression in the top that caught the drips from the ceiling and contained clear water. Another popular feature was a natural bridge near the ceiling in the second room and an opening which resembles a window between two rooms.
An article in June, 1947, in the Herald Whig reported that “Burton cave is interesting. It tends to be cozy but its crooks and changes provide a sense of the mysterious necessary for any cave worthwhile. Its walls, carved from the earth by water long ages ago, are rugged. The ceilings vary, in some places smooth with the appearance of sandstone, in some places hobnailed with tiny stalactites as the water carrying the lime from the rock drips to the floor. In other places the rocks form convolutions overhead.”
The cave has been reported to be about a quarter mile in depth or at a shorter length of six hundred feet. In all descriptions it angles steeply downward and heads east where it crosses under Mill Creek and terminates beneath a farmer’s field. There are places where the ceiling height requires a crouch and in one place a crawl through a low passageway to reach the back portion of the cavern.
As with all caves, there are some tales worthy of being told around a campfire. One is that two young boys were left at home on a nearby farm with strict instructions to stay put, but of course they didn’t. They entered the cave and lost their way, necessitating a search. Two days later they were found and rescued from a “steep pit” at the end of the Burton Cave. While this makes a great story, it seems unlikely that such a simple cave layout would require a days-long search. However there is a mention that the area of the cave in which the boys were found was afterwards blocked off. No subsequent mention is made of a blocked portion of the cave.
A ghostly tale concerns the experience of a family in the area for a picnic. Upon arriving at the location they were surprised and horrified to confront a tall figure robed in black standing before what appeared to be an altar with a lifeless woman lying upon it. Needless to say the family vacated the area pell-mell and went to fetch the authorities. When they returned with reinforcements, no trace remained of robed figure or anything else.
It is unfortunate that years of mostly unregulated public use led to the defacement of the cave and disfigurement of some of the natural deposits.
The cave was owned by the family of local farmer W. H. Tandy from its discovery until the 1960s. Quincy University then leased it to study its biology and for scientific research and environmental education. Then the Nature Conservancy then held it for a time and eventually released it to the Illinois Department of Natural Resources.
The cave and about 85 acres is now a Dedicated Illinois Nature Preserve. In 1997, a coalition of organizations including the Mark Twain Grotto, MTG, the Illinois Department of Natural Resources, Bat Conservation International, the MVOR Gating Fund, and other governmental and private organizations constructed a barrier about thirty-eight feet inside the entrance to the cave to protect the endangered Indiana Bat as well as up to four other species of bats which inhabit the cave during the year at various times. The barrier allows access for the bats but protects them from human interference.
Along with the endangered bats, the cave is home to some species of invertebrates that live their lives completely in darkness. As a result they have lost pigmentation and are blind. This kind of “Ghost” insect is one that can be proven to live in Burton Cave.
According to an IDNR spokesman, “A Dedicated Illinois Nature Preserve is the highest level of land protection the state offers. That designation means that every single item on the property is protected by law and cannot be removed, defaced, disturbed or destroyed. In addition the cave is currently closed to public assess due to white nose syndrome precautions and concerns of spreading its associated fungus. Any unauthorized entrance or any trespass/disturbance to the cave itself is punishable by law. “
Sources
Asbury, Henry, Reminiscences of Quincy, Illinois, Containing Historical Events, Anecdotes, Matters Concerning Old Settlers and Old Times, etc. Quincy IL: D. Wilcox and Son, 1882.
“Friendly Burton Cave Has its Own Fascination for Young Folks,” Quincy Herald Whig, June 15, 1947.
Illinois Nature Preserves Commission, Burton Cave, Accessed July 11, 2019. www.dnr.illinois.gov/INPC/Pages/Area4AdamsBurtonCave.aspx
Illinois Tidbits>>Adams County IL Tidbits>>Cities, Townships & Maps>> Burton Township Accessed July 11, 2019. http://www.pikecoilgenweb.org/comments.php?id=15456
“Nature Group Turns over Burton Cave to State of Illinois,” Quincy Herald Whig, Jan 7, 1982.





