Commerce, controversy at Fifth and Jersey

In 1914, the Chamber of Commerce of Quincy (known today as the Quincy Area Chamber of Commerce) began an ambitious project – the construction of a new office building at 201 S. Fifth.
After 100 years, the wheels of commerce still turn at the site, now home to Winters Insurance Group. However, the paths to and from construction were fraught with controversies. Ultimately, they led to the Chamber's reorganization.
In addition to contemporary newspaper accounts, the story was told by John A. Heller, then a member of the Chamber's board of directors and principal proponent of the building project. His booklet, published in 1917, is entitled, "Two Years' Inside History of So-Called Chamber of Commerce" and is available at the Historical Society of Quincy and Adams County. He locked horns throughout the project with the Chamber's president, George D. Levi, and secretary, Judge C. F. Perry.
The building was intended to reinvigorate the Chamber. In 1911 a group of young businessmen started the Young Men's Business Club instead of joining the existing Chamber. Heller, a former hospitality worker and businessman, challenged them to reconsider their decision. He pledged $1,000 in June 1911 toward the construction of a building for the Chamber, then located in rented rooms at 528 Maine. The gesture worked initially as the Chamber's membership soared.
The building project floundered until February 1914, when Heller approached W. Emery Lancaster, the Chamber president preceding Levi, about a building site. After some haggling, he bought the site at Fifth and Jersey from Frank Ricker, a local banker, for $4,500 and donated it to the Chamber.
The Chamber formed a building committee, which included Heller as treasurer and Levi as chairman. Ernest Wood was engaged as architect. He designed the three-story, masonry office building in the late Chicago style with strong Prairie school elements.
The bids came in at $30,000 to $35,000, significantly over the $25,000 target. In August 1914, Buerkin & Kaempen was granted the contract as the lowest bidder and construction began. Buerkin & Kaempen also constructed the Masonic Temple at 528 Jersey and the Fifth Infantry Armory between Fourth and Fifth on Jersey.
The office space was arranged around central corridors on the first and second floors, each of which included a meeting room and a brick hearth at one end. The third floor originally served as a single open display area for local businesses but was later divided in suites for rental.
In addition, the plans included a room at the north end of the second floor for Heller's own living quarters. He would serve as the building manager in exchange for the room.
To finance the project, the Chamber's Industrial Fund Committee committed $15,000 consisting of pledges from the members. How to cover the difference between that and the $30,000 total cost became a recurring source of contention. Ultimately, the Chamber borrowed funds from the Illinois State Bank.
In May 1915, the construction was lagging behind schedule. The basement flooded, and there was no money to pay Buerkin & Kaempen's latest bill. The architect, Ernest Wood, was having health issues and left town for a medical procedure. Heller loaned the Chamber $1,000 for one year to complete the project. The dedication was scheduled for July 15.
Levi appointed a dedication committee with Heller as chair. However, quickly thereafter Levi instead charged the Chamber's existing social committee with the task and asked Heller's committee to assist. The Chamber engaged the Hotel Newcomb as the caterer for the meal at a cost of $1 per plate, charging their guests $1.50 per plate.
Heller fought incessantly with Levi and Perry about many details of construction, financing and the planning the dedication. They hassled about exterior signage, interior lettering on doors and windows, the selection of movers, kitchen appliances, how to use the dumb waiters, use of the bathrooms and building storage, attracting tenants for the offices, arrangement of chairs and tables for the event, the number of waiters, the sale of tickets, how much to pay the caterer, and the delinquent pledges to the industrial fund.
Event tickets were hard to sell in part because the Chamber had been criticized by some businessmen for spending money on the building instead of attracting new businesses. Heller defended the project but was also critical of Levi's and Perry's leadership, including bungled attempts to bring meat packing houses to Quincy.
Finally, the dedication day arrived. Using the second floor as a banquet room, they served 196 guests (some reports stated 250 or more) with a dinner consisting of "grape fruit cocktail," olives, sliced tomatoes and radishes, followed by broiled spring chicken, new potatoes and green peas, and, for dessert, a choice of fruit salad, vanilla ice cream, cakes, cheese and water crackers. Coffee and cigars capped the meal.
They unveiled portraits of three "fathers," namely John Wood, founder of Quincy; Edward J. Parker, a founder of the Quincy Boulevard and Park Association (precursor to the Quincy Park District ); and Heller as the Chamber's champion. Mayor William Abbott spoke, among others. The attendees were then serenaded by the Chamber's Glee Club with songs including "The Goblins'll Get You if You Don't Watch Out."
Heller and the building committee resigned by June 1916 because of their differences of opinion with Levi and Perry. By early 1917, Heller was not re-elected to the Chamber's Board, for which he blamed Levi and Perry. In May 1917, Heller's tenancy in the building was terminated. He resigned as a member on June 30.
The upheaval at the Chamber did not go unnoticed. In March 1916, John E. Linihan, a newly elected member of the Chamber's Board, spoke at the annual meeting about the need for reconciliation.
"I understand that there has been a difference of opinion in the minds of some of the members of this Chamber regarding the wisdom and advisability of the building of this home for the Chamber of Commerce," Linihan said. "These men believed honestly that the money expended in the erection of this building could have been and should have been used for other purposes, such as attempting to secure new industries for our city."
He called on the members to respect the differences of opinion but accept majority decision and unite behind it. He also called for the prompt payment of the Chamber's remaining debt for the construction.
The Quincy Herald issued several editorials in summer of 1917, pleading for the Chamber to cease the "back biting" and work together. The newspaper called for the complete reorganization of the Chamber.
Levi soon retired as president, and Truman T. Pierson was elected as secretary in October 1917. Second vice president W.T. Duker became president. The first vice president had left Quincy. Pierson served as secretary and business manager for two years. By June 1919, the remaining $3,100 of debt was paid off. Pierson left under a cloud after an audit of the Chamber's operations revealed "lax" business practices but no improprieties. Nevertheless, the Chamber was on the mend.
The Chamber remained in the building through 1969. Thereafter, J.M. Winters & Sons, a predecessor to the Winters Insurance Group, bought and occupied the building.
Hal Oakley is a lawyer with Schmiedeskamp, Robertson, Neu & Mitchell LLP and a civic volunteer. He has authored several legal articles and edited, compiled and/or contributed to books and articles on local history.





