For faith and freedom: Settling in the land of Liberty

The first permanent settler in what was to become the city of Quincy is well-known: In 1822 John Wood built a cabin on land he had purchased from land speculator Peter Flinn.
Lesser known are Daniel Lisle and his family, who — also in 1822 — became the first settlers in what is now Liberty Township. Lisle built a horse-powered mill on his property, a critical factor for the growth of a community, and settlers did come. A post office was established with the name of Liberty.
A. H. D. Buttz arrived in 1831 and built a log store, thought to be the first in the region, although other sources claim his was second and that D. P. Meacham built the first. In the 1870s, Buttz’s son was still operating the store, by then in a large, two-story brick building.
Adams County was in the federal government’s Illinois Military Tract. Some settlers arrived with full ownership granted by the government, some purchased bounty land from owners and some were “squatters” who risked living on land they didn’t own, hoping to purchase it later. Records show that in Liberty Township, others simply seized the opportunity to live free on the government’s land—and one tried to sell it.
In 1830, a small group of Mormons became squatters southeast of Liberty and called their community Montgomery, but they stayed less than a year. After purchasing the land, A. H. D. Buttz tore the buildings down.
Paris T. Judy laid out lots to sell in Section 20 of Liberty Township, but it was discovered that he did not own that land. In 1836, a Mr. Dudley, who had actually purchased the tract, laid out the town of New Liberty on it. The post office was moved
there, and the name was changed for a time to match the location.
Adams County’s earliest settlers tended to be individuals and families who were Congregationalists, Presbyterians and Baptists from New England and Kentucky. Liberty was unique because most of its early settlers were members of a single Church of the Brethren congregation who came from what later became Union County, Illinois.
The Church of the Brethren, also called Dunkards, German Baptists or German Baptist Brethren, had established a congregation in Kentucky under the leadership of the Rev. George Wolfe. He had been a preacher in Pennsylvania before moving west, but records do not indicate that any of his own 12 children were converted under his ministry. The later conversion of George Wolfe Jr. impacted Adams County and the state of Illinois.
In 1803 George Jr. married Ann Hunsaker in Kentucky, a
slave state. Soon after, with Ann’s brother, Abraham Hunsaker, George Jr. made a wilderness trip into the Northwest Territory, where slavery was not allowed. They chose a site, and in 1808 their families and others left Kentucky and moved to near what would eventually become Jonesboro, in Union County, Illinois.
Shortly after the great earthquake of 1811-12, religious revivals surged in the area, and at a Methodist revival meeting, George Jr. was one of more than a dozen individuals who “made a confession of religion.”
Recognizing the doctrinal differences between the Methodists and the Dunkard faith of his father, George Jr. sent Abraham Hunsaker back to Kentucky for a preacher to come and baptize the converts.
One was soon located, and after the baptisms, a church was organized. George Jr. was ordained and became its leader. The little group built the first
Dunkard church in Illinois.
In 1827, the families of the congregation began moving to Adams County, which had been organized in 1825. The first settlers included the Hunsaker, Wagle, Lindbaugh and Hendricks families, followed by the Ebbert, Vancil, Walker and Lierly families.
The Rev. Wolfe arrived in 1831 with about 30 more Brethren from Union County and helped construct the Mill Creek Church west of Liberty. The first wedding
in Liberty Township united
Jacob Wigle and Catherine Hunsaker, officiated by the Rev. Wolfe. The village of Liberty was formally surveyed in 1836.
The Wolfe family of Liberty Township was to have an important influence in early Illinois politics.
An ardent opponent of slavery, the Rev. Wolfe rode to Springfield to convince legislators to not allow the new state of Illinois to become a slave state, as many Southerners hoped. Some credited him with doing more to see that initiative blocked than any other individual.
His son David served as a pastor in Liberty, the county supervisor
and as a representative in
the state legislature.
In the next generation, Fred Wolfe presided as a judge in Quincy.
By 1874, the Church of the Brethren near Liberty had more than 200 members and purchased land at the edge of the town to build a new church. Additional Brethren congregations were started near Barry, Loraine
and Kellerville. In 1894 the name was officially changed from Mill Creek Church to Liberty Church. The Liberty Church celebrated its sesquicentennial in 1981.
As the population grew, Liberty Township added schools and churches. The Liberty Presbyterian Church and the Christian Church were both organized in 1852 and held services in the brick schoolhouse built that year.
Pleasant View Baptist Church began in 1853, and the East Union School was built in 1869.
The Evangelical Lutheran Church of Liberty (called Zion Evangelical Lutheran in some sources) was organized in 1854 (or ’55), meeting first in “the Campbellite church,” then in the Presbyterian Church’s building that had been built in 1854.
A Lutheran pastor from Quincy came to preach in a home on Tuesdays for several years. Lutherans built their own church in 1870. Early Catholic services were held in family homes, and St. Brigid Catholic Church at Liberty was built in 1870.
Liberty prospered and slowly grew. Many present names and traditions can be traced to the earliest settlers in Liberty Township who had a strong enough commitment to personal and religious liberty to seek it in the place they lived and the name of their town.
Linda Riggs Mayfield is a researcher, writer and online consultant for doctoral scholars and authors. She retired from the associate faculty of Blessing-Rieman College of Nursing and serves on the board of the Historical Society.





