Honey Creek Township: Land of frogs and honey

In the early 1820s the first settlers in Quincy built cabins on the bank of the Mississippi, but many Adams County early residents did not consider a location on the river as necessary or even of any particular advantage.
The advantages that were more attractive than the waterway were the vast prairies interspersed with thick forests and streams -- a combination that offered fresh water, farmland clear of trees, and abundant timber for construction and firewood. The prairies and creeks were soon given names -- in what would become Honey Creek Township, near the geographic center of the county, Mendon Prairie was on the west, and the larger, marshy Froggy Prairie extended down the center.
The origin of the Honey Creek name is clouded in legend. Old records agree that a squatter named Haven built a cabin on Hog Branch in 1820, then only stayed a year or two, but gave the permanent name of the main waterway and eventually the township. He was credited with discovering a massive hive filled with honey beside the larger stream into which Hog Branch emptied, so he named it Honey Creek. But another old source says that so many bee trees were found all along that waterway, later locals gave it its name. Charles Fletcher, the first permanent settler in the township, came in 1825, the year Adams County was organized, and built his cabin near the mouth of Honey Creek.
In 1825 the new Adams County commissioners appointed a committee to ride across the county and scout for the best route for a designated east-west trail. In the Honey Creek area, they found the highest ridges and best-drained land they could cross, going from one landmark to another, and went around the swamp in the middle. The men blazed a trail from the southwest corner of the township to the north side of present-day Coatsburg. Trees were removed along that trail to facilitate travel, but the hills and ravines were not graded, and no bridges were built. The trail that crossed Honey Creek connected Quincy to Peoria, Chicago and the East, eventually becoming a stage road and post road for mail. An 1835 map of Honey Creek Township shows it designated as "The Old Trail."
Froggy Prairie, the marsh the trail skirted, reportedly got its name in a more unusual way than Honey Creek. Two decades after Fletcher's arrival, more settlers had come. A school had been built on the east side of the prairie in 1836, and several years later a second school had been added on the west side. An old settler told this story about how Froggy Prairie got its name:
"It originated at one of the old-fashioned spelling bees, where a school district at the west of the prairie was pitted against the home district. … March 25, 1844; at candle lighting, present both schools in full force; wild grass taller than a man; water, boot-leg deep full of frogs, which made so much noise that the teacher was compelled to pronounce the words at the top of his voice in order to be heard at all. A schoolgirl from the west district called the place Froggy… ."
Another writer elaborated, "In a pique, she exclaimed, ‘How could anyone be expected to spell in such a froggy place as this?' " The name stuck.
The Old Trail opened the way for settlement. "Within the decade succeeding Haven's arrival came such settlers as Edward Edmondson, Enos Thompson and sons, John Byler, H. B. Baldwin, J.E. Kammerer, Richard Gray, Joseph Pollock, Mrs. Irene Grigsby and Jabez Lovejoy, Daniel Gooding, the Shueys and the Whites. Dr. Joel Darrah settled in the spring of 1840."
Although Honey Creek Township is predominantly rural and has never exceeded 800 residents, two permanent towns were settled by 1855, only two miles apart: Paloma and Coatsburg. Decades before the towns were platted, a Free-Will Baptist Church had been constructed between their locations on the Old Trail, and worshippers traveled miles to attend. James White built his family's cabin within sight of the church in 1835.
Present-day Paloma was settled near the junction of the Old Trail and Honey Creek by Daniel W. Gooding in 1839, but the town grew slowly. Only two or three families lived in the immediate area. The Thompsons, three brothers with seven sons, built southwest of the town. "Their settlement became known as the Thompsons Settlement, and was soon a thriving center of industry and Methodism." Enos Thompson often preached to gatherings in their home. The Thompsons were coopers, and they stacked barrels and kegs high on wagons pulled by four or six teams of horses and carried them southwest on the Old Trail to serve Quincy's new meatpacking and brewing businesses.
Coatsburg was named after R.P. Coats, who surveyed and platted it in 1855, the year the railroad went through. It became part of the Chicago, Burlington & Quincy. Coatsburg contested Quincy to become the county seat in the 1870s. In the early 20th century, it still boasted a newspaper, a bank, a half dozen stores, a German Lutheran church with a membership of about 150, smaller Methodist and Disciples of Christ congregations, and a Modern Woodmen Lodge.
One other factor besides the Froggy Prairie limited the population growth of early Honey Creek Township. Like all of Adams County, it had been bounty land, but many of the veterans who had claims to the land in Honey Creek sold them to the Boston and New York Land Company. The federal government was selling bounty land for $1.25 per acre, but the Boston and New York Land Company set their price at $5 to $7 per acre. There were few takers.
In the 2010 census, Honey Creek Township had 720 residents -- fewer than 200 in Paloma, fewer than 150 in Coatsburg. U.S. 24 now follows the route of the Old Trail.
Linda Riggs Mayfield is a researcher, writer and online consultant for doctoral scholars and authors. She retired from the associate faculty of Blessing-Rieman College of Nursing, and is on the board of the Historical Society of Quincy and Adams County.





