Payson's Jesse Fell a key Lincoln man


Abraham Lincoln counted several Adams County residents among his most influential friends. Among them were Orville and Eliza Browning, Stephen A. Douglas, Thomas Ford, James Jaquess, Andrew Johnston, Abraham Jonas, Willliam Richardson, James Singleton, John Tillson, Archibald Williams and John Wood. They were teachers, lawyers, newspapermen, bankers, farmers, land speculators, temperance advocates, town founders, and civic leaders.
There was another Adams County resident who did all of those things and was as important as any in Lincoln's career. He was the first to recommend Lincoln for president. The man was Jesse W. Fell of Payson, whose idea in 1860 is credited with gaining Lincoln the Republican nomination for president that year.
Like several of his Adams County neighbors, Fell, had made and lost fortunes. It was during one of his boom-and-bust cycles that the 37-year-old and his wife Hester, 27, arrived in rural Adams County in 1845. They planned to develop a new enterprise, a nursery and fruit farm, just north of Payson, which Fell named "Fruit Hill."
Born in 1808 into a Pennsylvania Quaker farm family, Fell had attended a boarding school to study botany, the source of his lifelong interest in flowers and trees. To pay for his education, he taught in subscription schools, clerked, and sold books. In his spare time he read law. He passed the bar exams in 1832 in Ohio. He also developed an interest in politics, making stump speeches against President Andrew Jackson. Although the law firm at which he had clerked offered Fell a position, he declined. He wanted to move west.
Fell was admitted to the Illinois bar in November 1832 and at the suggestion of Springfield lawyer John Todd Stuart moved to Bloomington in 1833 to become the first lawyer in the town of 180 residents. Fell's interest in law waned and in 1834 and he was appointed McLean County's school commissioner. In the position he learned land speculation, which he found more interesting than education or law.
At about that time, several surrounding counties sought to annex parts of McLean County, which took Fell to the state capital at Vandalia to fight the efforts. During the winter of 1834-35, he shared a home in the capital with Stuart and Lincoln, both Whig legislators from Sangamon County. They proved helpful to Fell, who was named an agent for the new State Bank of Illinois. His education in the mortgage business gave Fell additional tools that would make him highly successful in acquiring land.
Fell left the law, selling his practice to recent Bloomington arrival David Davis, and prospered in the land business. He held large tracts of land in Illinois and Wisconsin, including Chicago and Milwaukee. Prosperity seemed endless. He founded and developed additions to a dozen central and eastern Illinois towns, the first Clinton in 1835. In the next decades he and others would found Pontiac, Lexington, Towanda, and more, and would be known for beautifying them with trees along the streets he platted. Fell also was responsible for additions to Decatur (with his partner, Lincoln clan member William Hanks) and Bloomington and dealt in lots in Joliet and Dwight. His most important development was his founding of Normal and winning Normal Teachers College for it.
Fell's role in politics became more active. He joined Lincoln in 1838 to work for Stuart against the 25-year-old Springfield Democrat, Stephen A. Douglas, for Congress. Although his political acuity was growing, Fell declined entreaties that he run for political office.
The nation's financial Panic of 1837 reversed Fell's successes in land speculation. By 1841, the western economy was devastated and Fell, now bankrupt, returned to the practice of law for income. By 1845, however, his interest in law waned once again. And once again, he sold his key assets-- his 190-acre farm and home -- to David Davis to settle debts.
That's when Fell secured his 62-acre tract one-half mile north of Payson, the southern Adams County village incorporated in 1839. Fell planned to develop his "Fruit Hill" nursery and farm to supply varieties of sapling trees and fruits to neighboring towns. He had his eye mainly on the business opportunities he saw in the growing river town of Quincy.
A Henry Clay Whig, Fell was a believer in Clay's "American System," which advocated banks, protective tariffs, and public works projects. With the founding of so many communities, Fell considered transportation systems like roads and rails essential to their prosperity and growth. His name was among those on a petition in 1835 to build the Illinois Central Railroad. When construction began he worked to get track through towns in which he had invested and sold timber from his lands in Southern Illinois for railroad ties.
To get his products from Fruit Hill to his largest market, Fell secured a straight, 12-mile road from Payson into Quincy. His experience in surveying and in land negotiations facilitated routes and land sales and easements.
Friends from throughout Adams County in 1850 asked Fell to represent them in the General Assembly, noting particularly his opposition to the spread of slavery.
"(Your views) on the really important question of the times--the non-extension of slavery," wrote Quincy attorney Nehemiah Bushnell, "will not only meet the approval of the entire Whigs of the county, but will I believe tend to secure a strong vote from the free-soilers, who probably in this county and certainly in the congressional district, hold the balance of power."
Fell then and again in 1854 declined. His single executive role in public office was as the first moderator of Payson Township when it was organized on April 2, 1850.
By 1851, Fell was harvesting 10,000 bushels of fruit from the 2,500 apple, peach, pear, plum, and cherry trees on his Payson farm. He believed it had the largest variety of gooseberry and currant bushes in the country. Although Fruit Hill was profitable, it was not as profitable as Fell had expected. He sold the farm, its house, barn, cribs, and two good wells to his brother Robert at the end of harvest in 1851.
Fell returned to Bloomington, where he resumed investments in land and behind-the-scenes activity in politics. In 1857, he became corresponding secretary of the Republican State Central Committee, by which he was able to take the pulse of the party. It was all he needed to know. In the McLean County Convention on June 5, 1858, delegates passed his resolution "that Lincoln is our first, last, and only choice for the vacancy soon to occur in the United States Senate." Less than two weeks later, delegates at the state convention in Springfield passed that resolution, almost verbatim.
Lincoln lost the race to Sen. Stephen A. Douglas. But the texts of the seven Great Debates -- the sixth was in Quincy on Oct. 13, 1858 -- had been printed and distributed throughout the country. Fell returned from an eastern trip where the response convinced him Lincoln could be elected president in 1860. Lincoln thought the idea was foolish but in his party role, Fell continued to promote it. And Lincoln, after visits to Kansas and Ohio in 1859, consented to Fell's request for his autobiography. Commenting on its brevity, Lincoln told Fell, "There is not much of it, for the reason, I suppose, that there is not much of me."
When Republicans met at the Wigwam in Chicago in May 1860 to choose their presidential candidate, Fell performed his greatest service for his friend Lincoln. Illinois leaders discovered that easterners who favored New York Senator William Seward as the Republican presidential nominee had monopolized the tickets into the Wigwam on the day the party's candidate was to be nominated. Aware of the importance of enthusiasm of the crowd to influence delegate voting, Fell had counterfeit tickets printed and distributed to Chicago's Lincoln supporters. On Friday, May 18, while Seward supporters marched outside, westerners favorable to Lincoln took their seats inside the convention hall. Seward's crowd was out-witted--his delegates had been seated away from undecided delegates--and out-shouted. On the third ballot, Lincoln became the Republican Party's nominee.
Fell sought no reward for his work, recommending instead that Lincoln appoint David Davis, leader of Lincoln's campaign committee, to his cabinet.
"Of all the men who led in Illinois affairs during the middle of the century," wrote Fell biographer Frances M. Morehead, "Jesse W. Fell has perhaps the distinction of being the most nearly forgotten, save in the places where he left the living monument of trees to speak of him to the generations other than his own."
Reg Ankrom is executive director of the Historical Society. He is a member of several history-related organizations, the author of a history of Stephen A. Douglas and a frequent speaker on pre-Civil War history.
Sources:
"For Sale," The Quincy Daily Whig. November 16, 1855.
"More Fine Fruit," The Quincy Daily Whig. September 21, 1855.
Morehouse, Frances M., "Jesse Fell," Transactions of the Illinois State Historical Society for the Year 1915. Springfield: Illinois State Journal Company, 1916.
Shelton, Helen Shepherd, "Payson Township," People's History of Quincy and Adams County, Illinois. Edites by the Rev. Landry Genosky, OFM. Quincy: Jost and Kiefer Printing Company, 1972.
Sage, Harold K., "Jesse W. Fell and the Lincoln Autobiography." Journal of the Abraham Lincoln Association. V3, 1981 at http://quod.lib.umich.edu/j/jala/2629860.0003.106?view=text;rgn=main
Stevens, Walter B., A Reporter's Lincoln. Edited by Michael Burlingame. Lincoln: University of Nebraska Press, 1998.





