Pinkham Hall deaths were not-so-rare tragedy

In 1862, Nathan Pinkham purchased land to build a livery on the north side of Maine between Third and Fourth streets. By 1863, Pinkham had remodeled the upstairs as a "variety hall." which he christened "Pinkham Hall."
Pinkham's establishment was dedicated on April 1, 1863, by the Needle Pickets, a soldiers' aid society of Quincy. Admission for the evening was 25 cents, but for an extra 25 cents "those wishing to dance" could stay do so.
Pinkham Hall was illuminated by gas fixtures. Gas lighting had come to Quincy 10 years earlier, when the Quincy Gaslight and Coke Co., with John Wood as president, inaugurated the city's system of mains and public lamps. The gas was produced by a system of coal-burning retorts at a plant at the corner of Eighth and Jersey streets.
Although the new auditorium was regularly used for lectures and entertainment, its reputation as a venue was not without critics. In July 1864 the local papers noted that "The defects of Pinkham Hall as a place for public speaking are well known…" and that the bricking up of all windows on the east side "has also a tendency to make matters worse, shutting off ventilation more perfectly than pleasantly."
In 1865, poor ventilation contributed to one of those small-scale tragedies so common to states at war. In February, after nearly four years of war, Quincy was once again the locus of troop recruitment and mustering, as it had been in 1861.
On Feb. 11 the Quincy Whig-Republican reported, "About four hundred of the newly enlisted recruits under command of Maj. Gen. Prentiss changed their quarters last Saturday evening to Pinkham Hall, where they are now provided with the very best accommodations. The General informs us that he will put in some four hundred more before to-morrow night…. The boys are as thick as three in a bed, and if the weather was a little warmer, would doubtless long for ‘a lodge in some vast wilderness' or other less crowded locality."
The tragedy at Pinkham Hall was reported by the Whig-Republican on Feb. 18. "Last Thursday night [Feb. 10] some of the new recruits quartered in Pinkham Hall blew out the light without turning off the gas and lay down under the burner to sleep. The next day two of them, Easom Patterson of Hancock County, and Wm. Abbott of Canton, Fulton County, died from the effects of inhaling the gas which had escaped through their carelessness or ignorance.… Mr. Patterson was about 30 years old, and leaves a wife and three children. Young Abbott was a minor. The remains of both have been sent to their respective friends for internment."
On Feb. 17, the Daily Whig had also reported that two more had died after the events of the 10th, one while being treated at Hospital No. 2 and the other at "Dr. Thorn's." Dr. Thorn was treating the men under his care with "electro-thermo baths" with "the most beneficial results."
The deaths continued. On March 6 it was reported that despite more than three weeks of treatment at the home of Dr. Thorn, E.S. Rollins, of Company E, 148th Regiment, had died the previous morning. The Whig reported that "His remains were removed this morning to his friends near Mill Creek this county for the last rites of burial." Another patient, however, had received two weeks of treatment and then been sent home to convalesce.
One soldier who was a witness to the deaths and suffering was Private Benjamin F. Weeks of Ohio, who was mustered into Company F of the 51st Illinois Infantry on Sept. 2, 1862. In a war in which more soldiers died of disease than battle wounds, Weeks was incapacitated by chronic diarrhea or dysentery. Unfit for duty, he arrived at Hospital No. 2 in Quincy in early 1865. Despite extensive medical attention, he was unable to recover sufficiently to return to his unit. Rather than face reassignment to the VIC (Veteran Invalid Corps) Weeks applied himself to learning basic nursing skills and was assigned to assist the hospital staff with mixing and dispensing medicines.
On Feb. 17 he wrote to his Uncle Otis in Decatur, Ala., from "2nd Division U.S. Gen. Hospital Quincy, Ills," inquiring about family matters, and relating how "The city [Quincy] has been thronged with recruits for several weeks and they are as green as ever I was…. They go gawking on every side of the street, stand in squads taking all the pavement insulting many of our fine ladies, they seem to think from their actions, that being a soldier gives them license to do every so many mean acts."
After acknowledging that the new recruits were "as green as ever I was," Weeks described the circumstances at Pinkham Hall. The men had, he said, "been crowded in it as thick as they can lay on the floor" and they, "through carelessness, let the gas flow among them, that is they blew the gas light out without turning it off."
He noted that the effects of the gas had caused a "terrible destruction" with the men becoming stiff-jointed, "delirious, raving like wild, or mad men all the time until a few hours before they die, when they get so that they are rational and sink away." He went on, "I tell you old soldiers would not be murdered in any such a way." Finally, he observed that many had been moved to hotels or private dwellings, and that all were "not so bad since the gas was shut off."
In all, 12 men succumbed to the effects of the mistake with the gas lamps at Pinkham Hall. As with any such inadvertent tragedy, their deaths, so near the end of the war and so far from the field of battle, illustrate the events large and small by which the history of any conflict is made.
Lynn M. Snyder is a native of Adams County, a semiretired archaeologist and museum researcher, a former librarian and present library volunteer at the Illinois Veterans Home, and a Historical Society of Quincy and Adams County board member and volunteer.
Sources
"Another Victim." Quincy Daily Whig. 6 Mar. 1865: 5.
"Change of Quarters." Quincy Whig-Republican. 11 Feb. 1865.
"Death of Soldiers from Inhaling Gas." Quincy Whig-Republican. 18 Feb. 1865.
"Elocutionary Entertainment." Quincy Daily Whig. 21 July 1864: 3.
"Grand Opening of Pinkham's Hall." Quincy Daily Whig. 20 Apr. 1863: 3.
Hicken, Victor. Illinois in the Civil War. Urbana: University of Illinois Press, 1966.
Hubert, Charles F. History of the Fiftieth Regiment Illinois Volunteer Infantry in
the War of the Union. Kansas City: Western Veteran Publishing Company, 1894.
"More Deaths from Inhaling Gas." Quincy Daily Whig. 17 Feb. 1865: 3.
Weeks, Benjamin F. 1864-1865. Letters in the collections of the Historical Society of Quincy and Adams County.





