Quincy woman takes her life after seeing witch doctor

On the morning of Sept. 26, 1904, Elizabeth Weisenberger of 328 State found her granddaughter, Bessie Bement, dying from poison ingestion.
Dr. E.H. Toole was called to the home between 8 and 9 a.m. to find Bessie comatose and dying from carbonic acid poisoning. According to the Sept. 26, 1904, Quincy Daily Journal, Dr. Toole "did all he could to save her, and called Dr. Hart with his stomach pump, but their efforts were of no avail, as the poison had been absorbed into the system." The coroner's jury ruled the death as a suicide. The empty bottle of carbonic acid, with the drug label K.S. Holt's, was found under Bessie's pillow.
What caused Bessie, a 19-year-old Quincy woman, to despair enough to take her own life in such a horrific way? As Quincy Police investigated her death, it became apparent she had seen a local "witch" doctor for depression and was under the spell of his voodoo cures.
When we think of witches, the image that comes to mind are women burning at the stake in Salem, Mass., during the 1600s. However, as people migrated farther into the Midwest in the 19th century and settled, they brought their old-fashioned beliefs and cures with them, including practicing a form of voodoo to relieve medical ills.
While popular opinion and the press maintained that only uneducated people still practiced voodoo or witchcraft, the reality is that many rural Illinoisans still believed in the power of magic and curses into the 20th century as evidenced by folk stories documented by Harry Middleton Hyatt and others. Bessie's sensational death and the media coverage surrounding her suicide is a glimpse into our medicinal past.
Dr. Toole told The Quincy Daily Journal that he had treated Bessie at various times in her life, and she often complained of "her lonesome condition but asserted she had no love affair."
In the same newspaper story, Dr. Bacher was described as "a pretended sorcerer, stooped beneath almost 80 years, gray, thin and feeble, who with his quavering voice says things that might make the credulous almost believe that he has just stepped out of the ages of the black arts."
According to Dr. Bacher's statement, he told Bessie to go home and find a reeth, a string holding a cluster of feathers, in her pillow. Bessie returned the next day with the reeth, where Dr. Bacher told her to burn it. He then gave her a steel belt that contained some powder to wear and prescribed a powder for her to ingest which "completed his course for witchery," according to the Quincy Daily Whig.
Bessie did not visit Dr. Bacher again, according to his claims. After Bessie's visit to Dr. Bacher, she attended the St. Louis Exposition for four weeks. In the same Daily Whig article, Dr. Bacher theorized she "probably failed to wear the hoodoo shield," which was the only reason he could provide for the return of her despondency and death.
The Quincy Daily Journal reported that the night before her death, Bessie had been seen at 10:30 p. m. when she had eaten a good supper but "felt bewitched and not like herself, and seemed as though she was petrifying; she said she had no feeling and denied any love affair."
The carbonic acid was not familiar to any residents in the house, but Bessie had something wrapped in a package when she arrived from St. Louis the previous week. The morning of Sept. 26, Dan Welch, a witness, said he saw Bessie lying unconscious on her bed about 8 a.m. He notified her grandmother, who found her and called the authorities. Bessie's funeral was held Sept. 28, 1904, and her final resting place is Woodland Cemetery. Dr. Bacher learned of Bessie's death when it was published in the local newspaper.
Dr. Bacher was no stranger to being in court, as he was put on trial in circuit court in 1901 for practicing medicine without a license. The jury acquitted Dr. Bacher because he had been a practitioner before state law required a diploma to practice medicine. It is interesting to note that Dr. Bacher was considered an expert on cancer care, though some witnesses claimed he was not well-known or well-liked among area physicians and kept to himself. The Quincy Daily Journal reported that during during Bessie's autopsy, it was found that she was in an "unusually diseased condition within the lower abdomen." While it is not clear what exactly the disease was that doctors found during her autopsy, they believed this gave rise to her despondency.
Dr. Bacher was not convicted of any wrongdoing in Bessie's death, but he did not outlive Bessie by long, succumbing to a six-month illness and dying at 1 p.m. Oct. 15, 1905, at his house at 1025 Broadway. During his illness he had suffered the "paralysis and infirmities of old age," according to a local newspaper.
Dr. Bacher was born Feb. 5, 1828, in Germany, and arrived in the United States in 1854, landing in New Orleans, where he stayed until he moved to St. Louis, where he enlisted in the home guards during the Civil War. He moved to Quincy sometime in 1877 where he practiced medicine as a "cancer specialist," though he never was accepted by local physicians. Dr. Bacher was buried in Greenmount Cemetery.
Bessie Bement's tragic story demonstrates the local belief in "voodoo" doctors, even if they didn't visit their establishments for cures. Stories such as Bessie's capture a snapshot of a society shifting from local cures and medieval beliefs about illness and moving toward the modern approach of balancing physical and mental health.
Melissa DeVerger is a librarian and a Quincy native with an interest in history.
Sources:
"The Death of Dr. Bacher." The Quincy Daily Journal, Oct. 16, 1905, p. 5.
"The Death of Franz Bacher." The Quincy Daily Herald, Oct. 16, 1905, p. 6.
"Girls' Suicide Reveals Death by ‘Witchcraft,' Startling Methods of Aged Quincy ‘Doctor'." The Quincy Daily Whig, Sept. 28, 1904, p. 1.
"Franz Bacher Died Suddenly." The Quincy Daily Whig, Oct. 17, 1905, p. 4.
"Franz Bacher Died Suddenly." The Quincy Whig, Oct. 19, 1905, p. 3.
"He Practiced Black Art." The Quincy Daily Herald, Sept. 28, 1904, p. 8.
Kleen, Michael. Witchcraft in Illinois: A Cultural History. Charleston, S.C., the History Press, 2017.
"News in Brief." The Quincy Daily Journal, Oct. 17, 1905, p. 8.
"Reveals Death by Witchcraft." The Quincy Daily Whig, Sept. 28, 1904, p. 4.
"State is to Investigate." The Quincy Daily Whig, Sept. 29, 1904, p. 1.
"Suicide of Young Girl." The Quincy Daily Journal, Sept. 26, 1904, p. 3.
"To Prosecute Dr. Bacher." The Quincy Daily Journal, Oct. 1, 1904, p. 5.
"Was Treated for Witchery." The Quincy Daily Herald, Sept. 28, 1904, p. 8.





