The Forest Hotel: A Siloam treat

In the late 19th and early 20th century, one highly specialized hotel in Adams County attracted hundreds of visitors each year, not only from neighboring counties, but from other states and even Europe.
Its annual opening for the May-to-October season was a newsworthy event. The famed destination was the Forest Hotel in the secluded community of Siloam, located in a little valley in Buckhorn Township, about 30 miles east of Quincy. (Some handwritten notes spell “Forest” with two Rs, but official documents have only one. One early article called it the “Forest Home Hotel,” but that name appeared nowhere else.) The hotel and the community that grew up around it were focused on one attraction: the many mineral springs in the valley.
Mineral springs were valuable. The painkiller aspirin was not patented until 1899, and the patent for it was held in Germany until after World War I. Until then, Americans who had aches and pains turned to natural remedies, and the waters from mineral springs were highly prized and advertised for their curative effects. Mineral springs supported hotels and resorts in many states.
George “Mohawk” Myers first acquired the tract with the springs on it when the government released the area as bounty land in 1852, then it was sold several times. Rev. Reuben K. McCoy, a Presbyterian pastor from Clayton, is credited with discovering and naming the springs sometime after the Civil War: Siloam was the name of the pool to which Jesus sent the blind man he healed in John 9:7. In 1881, Quincy Burgesser, a Clayton businessman, owned the land. Burgesser had the spring waters analyzed and found them to have “more strength than the water from the famous Eureka Springs,” due to the high magnesia, iron, and sulfur content.
Seizing the business opportunity, Burgesser began building a resort hotel on his land in 1882 and organized the Siloam Springs Company in 1883 to support and operate it. So many reservations were made before it was even completed that the plan was enlarged, and the resort opened with a 40-room hotel, a two-story bath house, and spring houses. The beautiful L-shaped hotel had balconies, a ballroom, and full kitchen facilities. There were tennis courts and croquet grounds. The three-day grand opening in May, 1887 attracted guests from as far as Colorado.
The little village of Siloam grew around the hotel — homes, school, post office, liveries, stores, a 200-foot swimming pool. Local guests arrived by road and those from farther away came by transportation provided from the Wabash railroad station at Clayton. An 1895 advertisement in The Siloam Herald, stated: “All persons desiring to come to Siloam from Baylis on the Wabash route will find first class livery rigs at cheap rates at Haines and Co’s livery stable.” Business thrived.
The original owner of the springs, George Myers, lived to be 102, and his longevity was credited to drinking the spring water. In the 1890s, J. B. House, a Siloam entrepreneur, sold the water and shipped it by rail all over the country at $3/barrel, or $2 more if he had to provide the barrel. Hotel guests could arrange to have the Siloam waters at home.
The Mount Sterling Democrat Message reported on June 18, 1909, that the new hotel manager, C. S. Johnson, had refurbished the hotel prior to the season opening, adding “new toilet rooms by (sic) both ladies and gentlemen,” 37 new rugs, 205 yards of new carpet, and 60 yards of linoleum, as well as new wallpaper and paint, 16 rocking chairs, and a piano in the parlor. He also added running water from a system run by a gasoline engine. Outside, he installed 930 feet of concrete sidewalks and 700 feet of boardwalks, a 1,000-foot lake with an island and a beach, and dressing rooms.
The guest books from the Forest Hotel for 1886-95 and 1909-14 are archived at the Historical Society of Quincy and Adams County and include signatures of world-famous guests. C. E. Ringling, renowned circus owner, registered Oct. 23, 1887. P. T. Barnum stayed there July 24, 1888. (The column in which the innkeeper checked whether the guest had arrived by auto or horse was left blank.) E. I. DuPont registered July 27, 1888, listing his home as Paris, France.
The number of guests fluctuated greatly over the following years, but Adams, Pike, and Brown County citizens supported the hotel. Baseball teams stayed there. Ladies from Quincy hired drivers to take them and their children to Siloam for day trips and overnight outings. Young people from Beverly, where their strict Methodist parents had prohibited dancing, came to the ballroom at the Forest Hotel on Saturday nights. In 1894, the Quincy Glee Club sang there; in 1888, the Fishhook Band performed.
The hotel was closed from 1912 to 1915, then Johnson resumed managing it, and July 15, 1924, he purchased it from the Siloam Springs Company. But the era of springs resorts was ending, and there was no way to revive the business. A decade later, J. S. Harwood bought the hotel at a tax sale and renovated it again, but he was only able to keep it open two seasons, then he sold it to the newly formed Siloam Recreation Club. The club intended to restore it and develop the area for recreation, and local citizens raised money to match the state’s contribution toward that goal. The hotel was remodeled in 1937, and the roads were graveled. But by 1940, the Club had negotiated to turn the entire Siloam valley into a state recreation area. The state opted not to restore or maintain the structures.
The last buildings were sold at auction by the state on Nov. 20, 1943, and dismantled for lumber. Cecil Noftz of Golden bought the hotel for $1,200. A news article that reported the day’s events speculated that there was enough wood in the hotel to build five modest houses. Today only the hewn stone foundation of the hotel remains, and most of the remnants of the town have been gone for almost 70 years.
The beautiful, steep-sided valley that used to be the location of the Forest Hotel and the town of Siloam is now part of the Siloam Springs State Park. Visitors who know where to look can find the sidewalks and foundation stones of the grandest building of them all, and on the west side of the road that forms a one-mile loop through the valley, there is a modest historical marker that simply states that the spot was the location of the Forest Hotel.
Linda Riggs Mayfield, EdD, is retired from the associate faculty of Blessing-Rieman College of Nursing. She is a researcher, writer and an editorial consultant for academic researchers and authors. Seven generations of Mayfield’s family have lived in Adams County.
Sources
Baldwin, Fred. "Memories Fade as State Sells Siloam Springs Hotel," Unattributed newspaper clipping, Archives of the Historical Society of Quincy and Adams County, November, 1943.
Brown County Board of the Schuyler Brown Historical and Genealogical Society, A History of Brown County, Illinois, 1880-1970, c.1972.
Genosky, Landry (Ed.). People's History of Quincy and Adams County, Illinois: A Sesquicentennial History. Quincy, IL: Jost & Kiefer, n.d.
Landrum, Carl. "Hotel's Hey-day at Siloam Springs," Quincy Herald-Whig (Quincy, IL). October 8, 2000.
Mayfield, C. A. "Notice to All Club Members." Internal Communication of The Siloam Recreation Club, Inc., Archives of the Historical Society of Quincy and Adams County, July 19, 1938.
Mohlenbrock, Robert. "Siloam Springs State Park: An Old Resort Area Now a Western Illinois Recreation Center," [Pamphlet]. Outdoor Illinois (1975).
Siloam Herald, Archives of the Historical Society of Quincy and Adams County, May 16, 1895.
Siloam Springs Recreation Club, Souvenir program for dedication of Siloam Springs State Park, Archives of the Historical Society of Quincy and Adams County, 1956.
Webber, John. "Siloam Springs Natives Want to Bring Crowds Back," Quincy Herald-Whig, November 19, 1989.





