Dan Porter, The One That Got Away

A hanging was scheduled to happen in August of 1893, and it was causing Sheriff Vancil to lose sleep. William Jamison would be the last person legally hanged in Adams County and the execution would go off without a hitch, but Sheriff Vancil didn’t know that. And he wasn’t about to repeat his disastrous mistakes from the previous attempt to conduct a hanging two years before. That one got away.
The Quincy courthouse was an imposing and beautiful building that occupied the block between 4th and 5th streets on Vermont. It served many functions. It housed the courts, many elected officials, the jail with its inmates, and the jailor’s private quarters where he and his family lived in part of the upper basement.
Security was adequate in the jail wing, but crude by modern standards. Thick iron bars and walls and padlocks provided reassurance that prisoners would remain incarcerated. But humans are ingenious creatures and what one can create, another can overcome.
The tale of the escape reads like a movie script. Dan Porter, with aid from another prisoner and/or a visitor, made or somehow acquired wooden skeleton keys that fit his cell padlock, and the door to the corridor. The keys were fashioned from a hard maple wooden broom handle, and somehow were whittled to match exactly the jailor’s keys.
Obtaining a key to the cell was only the first problem. The padlock was hard to reach through the bars, and the keyhole was in the bottom. It was not possible for Porter’s arm to reach through the opening down to the lock and then upwards to insert and turn a key. So, the key was screwed to the handle of a feather duster using screws from his harmonica and fastened at the correct angle for it to be used.
Porter unlocked his cell door and then two other doors and moved through the jailor’s room where he acquired two loaded revolvers, then through the basement to the Sheriff’s living quarters. There he entered the bathroom looking for an outside window. Sheriff Vancil, having checked the jail and turned off the lights earlier that evening, decided to take a bath. He undressed to his skivvies, entered the bathroom. Leaning over to check the water noticed two feet behind some clothing hanging on a hook. Straightening up he confronted a man with two revolvers.
Sensibly, he ran, chased by the man. Vancil managed with the help of his wife, to close and hold a door against the armed man. The man left and Vancil suspected he would try entry from another door and attempt to force the sheriff to open Porter’s cell and release him. Little did he realize that it was Porter himself, who returned to the bathroom and bent down the bars on the window to escape. These bars were much lighter than those near the cells, and Porter was a powerful man. By the time the sheriff dressed, went to check the cells, found Porter missing and managed to raise the alarm, the fugitive’s tracks in the early March snow lead nowhere.
Porter had pistols and a substantial lead. The Sheriff called out and deputized over a hundred men, and the alarm went out in all directions. Households were searched in Quincy. Riders went north, south and east. Telegrams went to all localities, but in spite of a spate of false alarms, Porter was not seen.
Porter’s mother lived in St. Joseph and the Missouri papers loved the story. Porter was eventually tracked down to a shed belonging to Charles Myers near Fairmont, Missouri, in the Kahoka area. Four local men armed with rifles, demanded his surrender. There are two stories from this point forward. The first says Porter surrendered a revolver and a straight razor but kept one pistol in reserve with which he shot himself rather than surrender. This story was adhered to until the four transported the body to Quincy where it was positively identified as Porter. At that point, Butler, one of the men, admitted to shooting and killing the man. There was a $1500 reward for the escapee, dead or alive. But prudently, Butler wanted to be sure it was the right man before admitting his part in the death.
After offering $1000 of reward money, the Adams County board of supervisors reneged and refused payment. On March 13th, they said they did not have the legal right to offer a reward, and so couldn’t pay it. Citizens were outraged, not least of all the four Missouri men who looked to split the money. A St. Louis paper said, “The citizens of the county are ashamed of their penurious Supervisors, who have refused to pay the $1,000 reward to the men who killed Dan Porter…The money is being raised by subscription.”
Dan Porter wasn’t done. If you believe the two men walking down the St. L. & N.W. Railroad track a mile south of Alexandria. They instantly recognized as Dan Porter, the man who appeared walking toward them on the tracks. The men said the spectre was silent, motioned to them with one hand, and pointed toward his head with the other. His head had a bullet hole in the back of it.
Not to be outdone, Quincy reported: “Considerable excitement has been raised here over a report …that three citizens, one a negro, met the spook of Dan Porter standing near the jail in the courtyard in Quincy last Friday night.” This spirit also pointed out a bullet hole in his head. Other sightings were reported along his escape route through Missouri.
Every odd occurrence at the courthouse was blamed on Porter’s ghost. When all the gas lights in the courthouse went out at exactly noon, Vancil laughed and said it must be Porter. Privately the sheriff said he and his deputies could keep the town entertained with ghost stories till at least the Fourth of July. After that, he thought it might be too hot to make them up.
Sources
“Dan Porter. Quincy Daily Journal , 02 March 1891.
“The Dan Porter Reward.” St. Louis Post-Dispatch , 13 March 1891.
“The Last ‘Fake.’ ” Quincy Daily Journal , 27 March 1891.
“A Murderer’s Ghost.” St. Joseph Weekly Gazette , 26 March 1891.
“Porter Captured.“ The Palmyra Spectator , 12 March 1891.
“Won’t Pay the Reward.” St. Joseph Gazette-Herald , 14 March 1891.





