Lima in the 1830s: Beauty and ashes

Communities are often named after famous people or natural elements unique to the area. The town and township of Lima, however, may claim the most unusual history of a name in Adams County.
In 1833, the year the town was platted, Dr. Joseph Orr built the first store. The custom of the day was to identify a store by the name of its town, but the tiny community had no name yet, and he needed a way to identify his new enterprise.
According to long-documented accounts, Dr. Orr had a house guest from the South American country of Peru. The traveler observed that he had not encountered women as beautiful as those in the area of the good doctor's store anywhere in all his world travels, except in the capital city of his home country.
Dr. Orr reportedly decided that such a compliment should be repaid by naming the community, and thereby his store, for that capital city -- Lima, Peru. Although the name of the South American city is Spanish, and therefore pronounced "lee'-muh," in Adams County, the i is always long. In 1850, the supervisors replaced the township's original name, Lafayette, with Lima, as well.
The first settlers in the township were Joseph Harkness and his family, who arrived from St. Clair County in southern Illinois in a covered wagon. According to some records, they arrived in 1828, and others, 1823 or 1825. His wife, Nancy, had been a Worley, and a Worley family had settled nearby in Ursa Township, in 1823.
The story was told that when the Harkness family was passing through the new settlement of Quincy, a shoemaker named Droulard noticed Joseph's beautiful pony. Droulard, a Frenchman and a veteran of the War of 1812, was Quincy's first landowner.
He rashly offered Harkness an entire quarter section tract in exchange for that pony -- land now in the heart of the city, between Broadway and Kentucky. But that pony was one of Harkness's most prized possessions, so he refused the offer and continued north into the wilderness with the animal in tow.
Harkness built a log house about two miles northwest of the current location of the town of Lima. Killum, Orr, William, and Grayson families soon settled nearby, and a town was platted in 1833. Grayson made the first bricks, William operated the first mill, and Dr. Orr opened his store and named the town. Many settlers came to the township in the 1830s, including Dazy, Wood, Archer, Ellis, Orr, Conover, and Selby families. James Selby was the first school teacher. John B. Carl organized the Christian Church, Disciples of Christ in 1830.
Although the higher ground, such as Pea Ridge, was some of the richest farmland in the county and had abundant game, the land on the western side had acres of swamp and snake-infested bogs. Men hunted in groups, for safety. On a group hunt in 1833, a den of snakes was found on Buel's Branch that contained 180 "serpents of all kinds twisted together."
Enormous change came to Lima Township in late 1838. In October, Gov. Lilburn Boggs of Missouri issued the infamous Extermination Order, which forced Mormons to leave the state by the following spring on penalty of death. Thousands of Mormons fled to Adams County.
Many Mormons were housed in Quincy, but their presiding bishop advised them to spread out. Until the next year when many moved north to Nauvoo, Joseph Smith's "Saints" settled in towns throughout Adams and neighboring counties and started their own communities, often as squatters.
Several Mormon families settled in and around Lima, and a new Mormon community was established north of the town on the Hancock County line, called Morley's Settlement, or Yelmor (Morley spelled backwards) Colony after their leader, Isaac Morley. Today the small Hancock County town of Tioga is located slightly north of the site of Morley's Settlement.
The center of Morley's Settlement, called Morley Town, had platted streets, houses, a barrel shop, a chair-making shop, four stores, and a school. The population of the settlement in the two counties was 400 to 500, including some 70 families. They were later combined with the Mormon families of Lima to form the Lima Stake (similar to diocese) of the Mormon Church.
Strong distrust characterized the relationship between the "old settlers" and the newly arrived Mormons for several reasons. Settlers who had already established homes and communities were highly aware that if the Mormons outnumbered them, and in Lima Township they did, the newcomers would control all the elections.
The Mormons had lost virtually everything they couldn't carry or haul when they fled Missouri in 1838-39.
Their prophet had already stated in his Doctrine and Covenants, in 1835, "… but behold it is not said at any time, that the Lord should not take when he please, and pay as seemeth him good; wherefore, as ye are agents, and ye are on the Lord's errand … and he hath sent you to provide for his Saints in these last days ... they shall obtain it."
Some interpreted that as permission to steal whatever the Saints needed. True or not, soon every loss of poultry, livestock, farming implements, or anything else of value, was attributed to the Mormons, but arrests were rarely made.
Reports of the Mormons practicing Joseph Smith's doctrine of "plural marriage" and proselytizing local women only added to the animosity.
On a June night in 1844, several men rode in and presented Morley with three choices for his people: Take up arms and help arrest Joseph Smith, move to Nauvoo, or surrender their weapons and remain neutral when fighting began at Nauvoo. Before giving an answer, Morley consulted with Joseph Smith and registered affidavits with government authorities, but soon most of the settlement's residents left their homes and moved to Nauvoo.
Within a few weeks, as many as 125 Mormon homes, barns, outbuildings , and businesses in Morley's Settlement were put to the torch, sometimes even before the occupants had left, but all escaped. The farm belonging to Solomon Hancock somehow was spared. Troops were sent to guard that farm, and it became the headquarters for gathering the settlement's harvest to take to Nauvoo.
Edmund Durfee and his wife, Magdalena, parents of 13 children, had fled to Nauvoo. On Nov. 15, Durfee and other men returned to the burned-out community to harvest their crops, sleeping at Hancock's. A mob of riders from Lima set fire to hay in Hancock's barnyard that night, then hid. When the Mormon men ran outside to fight the fire, Edmund was shot and killed. He was 57.
Fourteen of the 16 night riders, all from Lima, were identified, arrested, taken to Carthage, and arraigned, but all were released. None was ever tried. Legend says that the shooter was a man named Snyder who had murdered Durfee to win a bet.
Joseph Smith died in Carthage on June 27, 1844, the same month Isaac Morley had sought his advice on which of the three choices he should take for the future of Morley's Settlement. In January 1846, the Mormons began leaving Illinois for the Great Salt Lake Basin.
Today, Lima's 60 or 70 inhabitants and the township's approximately 550 residents (many surely still as beautiful as women in Lima, Peru) include descendants of some of the earliest families. Only ashes remain of the buildings of Morley's Settlement, and its 400 to 500 inhabitants never returned.
Linda Riggs Mayfield is a researcher, writer, and online consultant for doctoral scholars and authors. She retired from the associate faculty of Blessing-Rieman College of Nursing, and serves on the board of the Historical Society.
Sources
Black, Susan Easton & Richard E. Bennett, eds. A City of Refuge: Quincy, Illinois. Millennial Press, Salt Lake City, 2000.
First Converts in My Ancestry: Edmund and Magdalene (Lana) Pickle Durfee. [Blog.] http://firstconvertsinmyancestry.blogspot.com/2010/08/edmund-and-magdalena-durfee.html , August, 2010.
Genodky, Landry, ed. . Peoples' History of Quincy and Adams County, Illinois: A Sesquicentennial History. Jost & Kiefer Printing, n.d.
Launius, Roger. Roger Launius's Blog. Nauvoo and the Problem of Theft of Non-Mormon Property. http://launiusr.wordpress.com/2012/05/18/mormon-nauvoo-and-the-problem-of-theft-of-non-mormon-proper... , May, 2012.
Leeper, Tom. Personal interview. March 11, 2014.
Morley's Settlement (n.d.). Nauvoo Journal. Historic Sites & Markers. 153-155.
Parrish, Randall. Historic Illinois: The Romance of Earlier Days. A. C., McClurg & Co. 1906.
Wilcox, David F., ed. Quincy and Adams County: History and Representative Men. Lewis Publishing Company, Chicago, 1919.





