Quincy's Gov. Ford saved state's reputation

Historians rank Thomas Ford's record as Illinois governor from best to worst. Against overwhelming odds, he saved the state from bankruptcy and ill repute. His own reputation, however, was marred by the death of Mormon Prophet Joseph Smith.
A Quincy resident during the time he served as state's attorney of the Fifth Judicial District between 1830 and 1835, Ford was active in local affairs. When cholera struck in 1833, he helped design a system to halt its spread and to provide relief for the sick. As a prosecutor, his murder conviction led to what Quincy historian Henry Asbury believed was the first execution in Quincy.
Ford was the second of three Quincy men elected Illinois governor. Elected in 1842, he followed Thomas Carlin, a Quincy land agent, as Illinois' eighth governor. In 1860, Lt. Gov. John Wood, one of Quincy and Adams County's founders, served as governor for 10 months after the death of Gov. William Henry Bissell.
When Democratic gubernatorial candidate Adam Snyder of Belleville died three months before the August 1842 election, Democrats appointed Ford to replace him. A Supreme Court justice never elected to public office, Ford was slated only because he had done nothing anyone could attack. While other Democratic politicians shared blame for the state's failed economy, Ford had not been associated with it.
Ford took 54 percent of the vote in his victory over former Gov. Joseph Duncan of Jacksonville. Memories of Democratic voters were not as short as Whigs had hoped. Duncan had served as governor from 1834 to 1838, the period during which the national economy collapsed and a massive public works scheme in Illinois was leading the state toward bankruptcy.
Democrats might have forgiven then-Governor Duncan for conspiring with Whigs in the state's all-out spending spree in 1836 and 1837. But they would never forgive him for taking their votes in 1834 without telling them that he had switched parties. Duncan had been elected four times to Congress as a "whole-hog Jacksonian Democrat." But attracted to Whig Henry Clay's "American System" of banks, internal improvements (public works), and protective tariffs, he resigned, stayed in Washington, and ran for Illinois governor in absentia as a Whig. The state's Democrats got even in 1842 by electing their candidates to the governor's office and to majorities in the Illinois House and Senate.
Ford did not assume that the strength of his win gave him free reign in leadership. He was wise enough to know that as a governor who had not been a party leader, control of the executive and legislative branches guaranteed nothing. And he knew he would need his party's help to deal with the state's enormous financial problems.
During Duncan's administration five years earlier, Illinoisans were wild for public works projects -- railroads, roads, river and harbor improvements, which they believed were essential to growing the state's economy. Now, however, the Illinois-Michigan Canal was a big, unfinished ditch and state rails, roads, and navigable waters projects were costly disasters.
Once in office, Ford calculated that the accumulated debt for internal improvements was $10.5 million -- $239 million in today's dollars. State Treasurer John D. Whiteside reported to the General Assembly that the treasury contained $92.15 when the first bill for $123,571 arrived in late 1837. Illinois Auditor Levi Davis added that the state's annual revenue amounted to $67,500, little more than half needed to fund the payment. Davis pleaded for new revenue -- taxes. Gov. Carlin and the legislature ignored him.
As Ford reached office, Whigs and Democrats alike suggested that the state simply refuse to pay, or repudiate, its debt. Although he was no expert in finance, Ford's life experiences convinced him that repudiation would drive people from Illinois, saddle generations to come with debt, and severely damage the state's creditworthiness well into the future.
"We must convince our creditors and the world that the disgrace of repudiation is not countenanced among us, that we are honest and mean to pay (our bills). ...," he told legislators. They passed his remedial legislation.
Ford rejected Carlin's proposal to revoke state bank charters. Historian Robert Howard surmised that Ford did not want to alarm out-of-state financial markets, from which additional loans would be needed in reorganizing the debt. Ford arranged for the banks to trade at face value state bonds and notes they owned for depreciated bank stock that the state owned. This measure alone eliminated $2.3 million of state debt. Ford also reversed Carlin's rejection of proceeds from the sale of federal land in Illinois. And he sold off property that had been bought for public works projects that would not be built.
Ford calculated that completion of the $4.5 million Illinois-Michigan Canal would be profitable -- for an owner other than the state. He got its bondholders to provide the additional $1.6 million needed to finish the canal by transferring ownership to them. The canal became operational in 1848 and its tolls serviced its debt.
Ford also succeeding in winning the legislature's approval of a property tax to pay off all of the states debts. It took a quarter century to do it.
For Ford's success in maintaining Illinois ‘creditworthiness, most historians rank him as one of Illinois' greatest governors. But his record in a single event during the "Mormon Wars" of the 1840s has largely offset that.
On June 17, 1844, a Carthage delegation traveled to Springfield to ask Ford to raise a militia unit to keep peace in Hancock County. A week earlier, Mormons had destroyed the press of the "Nauvoo Expositor," which in its only edition opposed Smith and the Mormon leadership. At a meeting in Carthage on June 11, resolutions were passed that demanded Mormons turn over Smith and other leaders or face "a war of extermination." Ford decided to go to Carthage to sound out the depths of the problem.
Arriving in Carthage on the morning of June 21, Ford found an armed force of 1,700 men, which he placed under state militia officers to preclude a renegade posse from attacking Nauvoo. He then conducted an inquiry into the allegations made by the Carthage committee, including interviews with citizens of a Mormon committee. His investigation determined that the proceedings of the Mormon mayor, common council, and municipal court had been illegal, and he decided to order the arrest of the Mormon leaders for destruction of the "Expositor" press.
Ford assembled state militia forces at Carthage. By the volunteers' unanimous vote, he received their pledge to protect the Mormon prisoners. Ford assured Smith, his brother Hyrum, and members of the council that they would be safe if they submitted to arrest. All surrendered by June 24. Members of the council were immediately released. Joseph and Hyrum Smith, however, were held on a new charge that accused them of treason.
Believing that the 15,000 Mormons at Nauvoo would inhibit threats against the Smiths, Ford decided to send all but three companies of militia home. Two would protect the Smiths at Carthage jail and the third would accompany Ford to Nauvoo, where he obtained commitments for calm.
It was on Ford's return to Carthage that two men, one a Mormon, reported the Smiths had been killed. In his state history, Gov. Edward Dunne wrote that the eight jail guards had conspired with the assassins by firing blank cartridges as the mob of some 200 men with blackened faces attacked the jail and killed Joseph and Hyrum Smith. Ford on June 27 ordered 300 Quincy Home Guards to Nauvoo to keep peace. Fearing that an "outpouring of their (Mormon) indignation" would lead to his assassination, Ford left for Quincy, where he stayed for the next month.
In the last years of his life and nearly broke, Ford wrote his "History of Illinois," which scholars recognize as an important recollection of Illinois' early history. A copy of the work is shelved in the historical society's library.
Reg Ankrom, an amateur historian, is a member of several history-related organizations, the author of a history of Stephen A. Douglas, and a frequent speaker on pre-Civil War history.
Sources
Asbury, Henry. Reminiscences of Quincy, Illinois. Quincy, Illinois: D. Wilcox & Sons, 1882.
Caton, John Dean. Early Bench and Bar of Illinois. Chicago: Chicago Legal News Company, 1893.
Dunne, Edward F. Illinois: The Heart of the Nation. Vol 1. Chicago: The Lewis Publishing Company, 1933.
Ford, Thomas. A History of Illinois. 2 vols. Edited by Milo Milton Quaife. Chicago: The Lakeside Press, 1946.
"Biography." Peoria Democratic Press, December 18, 1850, at www.peoriacountyillinois.info/bios/1902bios_f.html#fordthomas
The History of Adams County, Illinois. Chicago: Murray, Williamson & Phelps, 1879.
Howard, Robert. Mostly Good and Competent Men: Illinois Governors 1818 to 1988. Springfield, Illinois: Illinois Issues, Sangamon State University, and Illinois State Historical Society, 1988.
Huntress, Keith. "Governor Thomas Ford and the Murderers of Joseph Smith," Dialogue: A Journal of Mormon Thought. Summer 1969.
Pease, Theodore Calvin. Illinois Election Returns, 1818-1848. Springfield, Illinois: Illinois State Historical Society, 1923.
"Report of the Auditor of the State of Illinois to the General Assembly, December 13, 1838," Reports Made to the Senate and House of Representatives of the State of Illinois at Their Session Begun and Held in Vandalia, December 4, 1838. Vandalia, Illinois: William Walters, Public Printer, 1839.





