Story of a familiar hospital picture

The 1891 picture above of the entrance arch to Blessing Hospital may be familiar to some readers. It was taken sometime in June of that year. The picture was first published in the newspaper on Feb. 11, 1940, under the title, “Blessing Hospital 50 Years Ago.”
It was subsequently prominently used during the 125th anniversary of the hospital in 2000. It was on the cover of that summer’s edition of “Personal Blessing,” a hospital publication sent to area residents. Today the doorway arch is at the top of the fountain in the Founders Garden just south of the main entrance to the hospital and a Lucite sign explaining the garden, uses the picture.
William Borthwick (1872-1973) sent the picture to Myrtle McAhren, the hospital administrator in 1940. He self-identified as the young man on the left. Thus began a correspondence with the hospital administrators, Myrtle McAhren, Harriet Foresman, and Leonard Hamblin that lasted until 1962. They told him about Quincy and the improvements to the hospital, particularly the 1952 and 1960 additions.
Borthwick often praised the Quincy of his youth and enjoyed the success of the hospital. He said in a 1952 letter, “Many times in the last 60 years, I have asked the blessings of our heavenly farther on the institution for which you and the good people of Quincy have labored so long, and with what splendid results ... God has blessed your efforts.”
He would visit the community every few years to see family and friends and was on occasion interviewed by the Herald-Whig. Although his obituary was published in the paper on Jan. 8, 1973, his last reminisces were in the Oct. 24, 1963, newspaper.
William Borthwick was the son of William and Martha Likes Borthwick. Newspaper accounts vary on whether he was born in Kinderhook or Barry. His father was a contractor who did construction work for the railroads. He came to Quincy at 17 to be a stable boy and carriage driver for the Col. Edward and Mrs. Virginia Prince, and their daughters Birdie and Mamie, who lived at 1680 Maine. Prince was superintendent of Quincy Water Works from 1873-1904.
At age 18, Borthwick was sent to Blessing Hospital with a back injury. He recalls in a 1946 letter that he “did not have a dollar. Dr. Hatch operated on my spine and I was many months in Blessing Hospital cared for without charge. That instance impressed upon me the need to support hospitals and it has been my good fortune to be able during my life time to be of assistance in raising funds for many hospitals.”
At that time Dr. Henry Hatch who lived at Fourth and Jersey, was a former professor of anatomy at Quincy Medical College (1882-1887) and former physician in charge of Blessing Hospital, 1882-1885. After recovering, Borthwick stayed on to work at the hospital as an aide and morgue attendant Luckily for Quincy, Borthwick recounted what he remembered about the people in the picture. On his left is Jennie Mitchell (Jane Isabel Mitchell) who became a nurse, graduating from the Blessing Hospital Training School for Nurses as a member of the second class in 1895. The training school was on the first list of accredited nursing schools after the State of Illinois established the licensure act in 1909. As a graduate of an accredited school, Jennie was grandfathered in as a licensed nurse (RN) and worked at the Illinois Soldiers and Sailors Home (now the Illinois Veterans Home).
Seated to her left is Judge William H. Cather (1813-1894). He arrived in Quincy in 1837, rode the law circuit with Abraham Lincoln and was elected county judge in 1853. He built and ran the Tremont House (Hotel) in 1856, originally known as the Cather House. Even though a Democrat, he was a friend of Lincoln and always referred to the martyred president as Abe. He is buried in Wesley Cemetery in Ellington. We can date the picture fairly accurately as the Board of Lady Managers of Blessing Hospital decide to send Judge Cather to St. Vincent’s Home in July, 1891 as he no longer needed hospital care. Standing on the left of the doorway was Mrs. Mary Bimson Lasieur, who is identified as the mother of Jennie Mitchell.
We know more about the woman standing in the center of the doorway that Mr. Borthwick identified as the hospital superintendent. Her name is Sarah Hessey Millen. She was born in 1855 to William and Elizabeth Hessey who moved from Missouri to Burton Township and later to 1825 Maine. She graduated from the Keokuk College of Physicians and Surgeons in 1882, and became the Superintendent of Blessing Hospital in June, 1891. The Quincy Daily Journal, Oct. 6, 1891 says she resigned her post because the hospital was starting a nursing school and that in order to sign a diploma, the superintendent had to be a graduate nurse. The Board regretted her resignation as she “has made a capable, trustworthy and painstaking matron, and has given good satisfaction. Her departure will be regretted by all who know of her good work.”
When the picture was published her relative, Mrs. Hugh C. Lawless of North 20th Street recognized her. She gave a picture of Dr. Millen to the hospital in 1952. According to Mrs. Lawless, Dr. Millen returned to Quincy to care for her ailing mother and assumed the duties of superintendent. The Board of Lady Managers minutes call her a nurse and a housekeeper. Sometimes they refer to her as Mrs. and sometimes Dr. To her immediate left is Miss Maude Cole of Marietta GA, and the last woman standing is tentatively identified as Miss Connell. They were both pupil nurses who did not complete the training.
Sitting on the steps in the middle of the doorway, directly in front of Dr. Millen, is Mrs. John A. Logan, who was most likely the cook. Mr. Borthwick mentioned she named one of her children Centennial (born in 1876). When the picture was published in 1940, the hospital received a letter from Elmer Centennial Webb of Hannibal , Mo., who said, “Gee! I got a kick out of that picture. I am the Centennial that was spoke of in that picture. At that time we lived the first house east of the hospital on Spring.” Seated to her left is Olive (last name unknown). She came to the hospital as a complete paralytic but could walk when this picture was taken. She answered the phone and ran errands. Lastly is Uncle Blue (name unknown), star border, who swallowed nitrate of silver and turned blue.
Unfortunately the person sitting in the window in the top left of the picture is unidentified but Mr. Borthwick remembered that the room directly behind Uncle Blue was occupied by Jim Wallin, editor of the Quincy Whig, who died in the hospital. Mr. Borthwick also recalled that the father of Neysa McMein (who was profiled in this column in 2011) was a patient at the same time.
Borthwick later became a mortician in Kentucky and Connecticut before marrying the former Ida Smith of Barry. His sons William and Harry were born in Barry before the family moved to the West Coast and on to Hawaii in 1916. He continued in the mortuary business. Borthwick founded the Honolulu Savings and Loan Company in 1929, became the tax commissioner for the Territory of Hawaii, and was a delegate to the territorial House of Representatives before Hawaii became a state.
With this picture, we have a window into the past. When the picture was first published, Borthwick was quoted in the accompanying newspaper article saying, “I was pleased to note the expansion and all-around improvements in Blessing Hospital. It was a blessing to me and may it continue to be a greater blessing as time goes by.”
Arlis Dittmer is the library coordinator for Blessing Health System. During her 25 years with the library she has been interested in the history of the institution, nursing history, and medical history; all topics often ignored in history books. She curates the archival collection and regularly answers historical questions for the health system and the public.





